> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Letter: Responding to John Marciano on Israel, Palestinians and Anti-Judaism
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/101304-story-20041013/
- Published: 2004-10-13T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T05:17:21.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ivan Smason, Ph.D., J.D. Santa Monica*

John Marciano asked, “Who is ignorant?” in his response (SMDP, Oct. 11, page 6) to previous letters that supported a local business owner’s decision to express her seemingly minority opinion on the continuing violence in and around the country of Israel. I’d appreciate the chance to address the matter.

Marciano wrote a prototypically anti-Israel (actually, anti-Jewish) piece that referred to an apartheid wall, oppression of poor native non-Jews, and fascist and racist Israelis and their supporters. He misleadingly stated that “We must ultimately confront the fact that the Palestinians are ‘the natives of Israel, an indigenous community excluded from nationhood in its own homeland: Dispossessed and expelled... denied many fundamental rights and exposed on a daily basis to injustice...’”

Unfortunately, anti-Judaism has been and very much remains the order of the day, and only in the case of a group making a competing claim against Jews, has the world so adamantly demanded and adhered to notions of “occupied territories” and recognition in name (”Palestine”) of a state that has never existed.

From Israel’s rebirth in 1948 until the Six Day War in 1967, Jordan controlled the so-called “West Bank.” During that span of time, Arabs regularly attacked Jews in and around Israel, but there were no “Free Palestine” posters and T-shirts all over Hebron, Europe or America aimed at Jordanian occupation, oppression, racism and apartheid.

There were no sophomoric American or European college students protesting the Egyptian occupation of the Gaza Strip during that same time. No one was questioning Egypt’s weak, and seemingly non-existent and illegitimate claim to the Sinai Peninsula; nor were they arguing that the Sinai should be duly returned to the descendants of the Romans, Persians or Judeans who owned it in the past. Only the tiny Jewish country of Israel is subjected to the horror and falsehood that portions of its land, clearly vital to its sustainability and natural growth, are classified as illegitimate or merely occupied.

I see all of the “Free Palestine” paraphernalia everywhere all the time, and it is always premised on the weak notion that there are non-Jewish Arabs who are an indigenous native community robbed of their rightful homeland by the Jews. I find it peculiar that any fair-minded American can be (1) obsessed with the plight of Arabs who make a competing claim against Jews for land in and about Israel, especially Samaria and Judea, and (2) relatively acquiescent about the much stronger counterclaim that our own native people make to Alabama, North and South Dakota, Indiana and most, if not all, of our country. For every “Free Palestine” poster, we should see 10,000 “Free Native America” posters at so-called “peace rallies” in Santa Monica, Europe and across the globe. We do not see this for reasons of ignorance and bigotry.

Ignoramuses have never sympathized with our great native population and its competing, and superior, land claims within our humungous country. However, when a much smaller and much less legitimate population of anti-Jewish natives on the other side of the globe makes a competing claim for a minuscule tract of land against incessantly beleaguered Jews with vastly superior claims — well, that seems to be a whole other (actually, ignorant and bigoted) matter.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 13, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/101304.pdf?ref=smdp.com)