> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# America’s health care system needs an overhaul, but who’s going to pay for it?
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/americas-health-care-system-needs-an-overhaul-but-whos-going-to-pay-for-it/
- Published: 2003-12-02T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:19:35.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Todd Flora*

While there is hardly universal applause in the policy community or even among seniors for the package the House and Senate have passed, AARP (America’s premiere seniors organization) has reportedly seen the long view on this issue and banked on its emerging Baby Boom membership in endorsing the plan. Republicans rejoice at their presumed preemption of senior voters from the Democrats in 2004.

Never mind that Congress hasn’t a dime to spare, and that this reform was worked through Congress without any care to its fiscal impacts. Organizations like the Concord Coalition have wisely pointed out that a prescription drug benefit should have been added as part of an overall reform package that restrains total Medicare costs. This sweeping “reform” won’t put the reigns on increases in drug costs one iota. In fact, it will add to them. There are several additional downsides, among them: ■Rather than structurally reform an already beleaguered system, this plan will simply pile a new benefit on top of an already unsustainable one. ■Rather than consider seniors with the lowest incomes or highest drug costs, the new benefit will add an estimated 20 percent to Medicare’s long-term cost. This estimate may even be low if a larg-er-than-expected number of employers drop their retiree drug coverage as a result of the bill. ■Rather than make Medicare more efficient on a wide scale, the bill is limited to a small “demonstration project” that requires the traditional fee-for-service program to compete with managed care alternatives. But that isn’t even scheduled to begin until 2010\. Congress has instituted absolutely no enforceable cost-containment mechanism whatsoever.

Never mind that reversing the Bush tax cuts and eliminating all spending on the war in Iraq STILL would not offset the cost of the Medicare prescription drug benefit. The $400 BILLION price tag for Medicare prescription drugs over the next 10 years is just one reason. But the hundreds of billions more in the following 10 years as the tidal wave of retiring Baby Boomers hits its apex adds insult to injury. The resulting deficits will make Reagan, Bush I, and Bush II deficits look like the good old days.

Never mind that the federal government spends nine times on seniors what it does on Americans 18 or under. Even when state spending on education is factored in, the ratio of financial resources dedicated to seniors versus young people is still 3 to 1\. Many of you reading this column may be proud members of AARP. Good for you. In addition to providing Medi-Gap coverage, AARP successfully advocates for seniors on a wide range of issues. Two noble battles have been AARP’s fights against telemarket-ing fraud perpetrated on our most vulnerable seniors, and exposing “predatory lenders” from trapping seniors into loans with devastating fine print.

But the powerful AARP — second only in membership to the Catholic church — has done wrong by future generations by demagoguing the argument that Medicare and Social Security don’t truly need reform. They need MAJOR reform in order to be “saved,” and the organization would do right by its New Deal legacy to be part of the solution, rather than continuing to be an impediment.

Doing the right thing should entail providing health coverage — including a prescription plan — to ALL Americans, regardless of age. But why do we consistently fail to take responsibility for finding a revenue source for new spending? Regardless of political party or ideology, we must begin to discipline ourselves to offset spending on major new initiatives with cuts or tax increases. No longer can we spend our way to social and economic justice without budgetary justification simply because a particular program is more noble than a war. Spending is spending. We have a moral responsibility to future generations to hand them a country in better fiscal order than we find it today. (Todd Flora is a six-year resident of Santa Monica. He is a government relations representative with a statewide children’s network, and the former western regional director of The Concord Coalition, a nationwide fiscal watchdog organization. To comment or reach Todd, e-mail him at:)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 2, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/120203.pdf?ref=smdp.com)