> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# An agent of Satan takes on Mel Gibson’s ‘Passion’
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/an-agent-of-satan-takes-on-mel-gibsons-passion/
- Published: 2004-02-25T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T03:52:12.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ed Silverstein*

I have learned some interesting facts recently. Apparently I killed Christ. I am also an agent of Satan. At least according to the Gospel of Mel.

Today Mel Gibson, star of the “Mad Max” and the “Lethal Weapon” series, and director of “Braveheart,” (renowned for their scenes of sadistic torture and shots of Gibson’s butt) will release his controversial new film, “The Passion of the Christ.” The star was apparently inspired to make the film after a bout of guilt resulting from abuse of alcohol, drugs and other addictions he declined to discuss that left him so despondent that he considered throwing himself out of a window.

I have no objection to films that celebrate the life or death of any religious figure. And anyone interested in seeing this reportedly excessively violent and nauseatingly gory picture should do so. Though I do strongly disagree with religious leaders who suggest that the hard R rated film is appropriate for children as young as 11\. What concerns me is the intent and motivation that leads Mr. Gibson to portray the final days of Jesus in the manner he chose.

Gibson claims he wanted to make a film that was absolutely true to the gospels. According to John Meacham’s comprehensive Newsweek piece entitled, “Who Killed Jesus,” the problem with using the gospels as … well, gospel, is that the writers “shaped their narratives several decades after Jesus’ death to attract converts and make their young religion.” In addition, the gospel writers were almost certainly compelled to depict the ruling Romans more favorably out of fear for their religion and their lives.

In any event, Gibson chose to cherry pick script elements from the diverging and conflicting gospels that support his long discredited and repudiated “traditional” Christian beliefs. Another source for the film, which Gibson speciously denies, are the visions of a controversial, 18th century nun, Sister Anne Catherine Emmerich, who today would be a diagnosed schizophrenic — probably living on the streets of Santa Monica.

Though I will not endeavor to detail all of the numerous inaccuracies pointed out by Meacham and others, of particular note is that Gibson depicts Pilate as a reluctant executioner forced by the Jewish high priests to execute Jesus. In fact, Pilate was reportedly “inflexible, stubborn, cruel and guilty of executing troublemakers without trial.” Other writings of the time directly accuse Pilate of ordering Jesus’ death. And Rome was the only authority that could order crucifixion. This was the penalty for sedition, not blasphemy, which makes sense when you consider that Jesus’ rising popularity would have been construed as a threat to Roman rule.

So was Gibson unaware of the historical context or the inconsistencies in his film? The answer is, no.

Professor Paula Fredrikson (“Mad Mel”, The New Republic, July 28, 2003) was among nine notable New Testament scholars, both Christian and Jewish, who were provided an early copy of Gibson’s script for comment. Though they never spoke to Gibson directly, the actor conveyed through the film’s Aramaic and Latin translator, William Fulco S.J., that he was very interested in their opinions.

According to Fredrikson, all members of the panel independently determined that the script was deeply flawed, and they were concerned that the inaccuracies were potentially divisive. The professors compared notes and wrote up detailed suggestions on how to make the script more accurate, which they supported with comprehensive historical documentation.

But instead of addressing their concerns, Fredrikson tells us that Gibson’s lawyers released accusations to the media that the theologians had stolen the script. Gibson’s company further claimed that the scholars were trying to sabotage the project by extorting Gibson into making a film that conformed to their views.

If Gibson knowingly made such false accusations, one has to wonder if the actor’s newfound belief embraces honesty as one of its tenets or if anything goes as long as it advances his cause.

Also in question is whether Gibson is an anti-Semite, a charge he vehemently denies. In fact, the actor has claimed that some of his best friends are Jews.

Mr. Gibson’s father, however, is a notorious Jew hater. He adamantly asserts that the Jews killed Christ, that the Vatican II is a plot engineered by Jews and Free Masons, and that the Holocaust never occurred. And it is the father’s extreme religious views that are represented in Mel’s “The Passion.”

This is not to infer that Gibson shares all of his father’s beliefs. However, when the actor was initially asked if he believes in the Holocaust, his reply was that a lot of people, including Jews, died during World War II. Such a disingenuous, nondenial denial has the same evasive lack of credibility as when Bush responded to Tim Russert’s question about whether he was AWOL by stating that he was honorably discharged.

Aside from Gibson’s ignoring of historical priorities, there is also the question of the offensive depiction of the unrelenting violence and torture of Jesus. Some suggest that Gibson is obsessed with sadistic imagery, and the actor himself has stated that he toned down the film. Gibson has claimed it was to show the extent of Christ’s sacrifice. But as the veteran of dozens of action flicks, Mel is well aware that such graphic torture does less to elicit sympathy for the protagonist than to incite anger against the antagonist. In Gibson’s film, they are Jews.

Considering the rising anti-Semitism around the world (and if my hate mail is any indication, in America as well) the choices Gibson has made for this depiction of Jesus are wildly irresponsible. I can’t unequivocally state that Gibson is an anti-Semite, but if he isn’t, then he is an incredibly insensitive and clueless man. And should “The Passion” result in even a single incident in which a Jew is harassed, attacked or even killed, I have a suggestion for Mr. Gibson: Next time you feel so despondent over your own questionable behavior that you consider jumping out a window …

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 25, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/022504.pdf?ref=smdp.com)