> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Building blase leaves little to imagination
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/building-blase-leaves-little-to-imagination/
- Published: 2005-08-19T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:43:23.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*OUR TOWN*

*By TED WINTERER*

In my last column, I railed on City Hall at how often it issues a Request for Proposals (RFP) from design-build teams when it seeks plans to construct new public buildings. This approach may work for the Marines’ Osprey tilt-rotor aircraft, but it too frequently fails to yield the best architecture in civic structures.

Consider the selection of a design-build team for the restoration of the city-owned property at 415 Pacific Coast Highway, the site of the old Sand and Sea Beach club. A RFP was published on two dates in the LA Times and sent to more than 90 design, engineering and construction firms chosen by city staff. Unless you scoured the Times or were on the city’s preferred list, you wouldn’t have known about this gig. In fact, a distinguished local architect on our Architectural Review Board told me he wasn’t aware of the RFP until it was too late.

Out of this less-than-extensive outreach to the design community, the city received three qualified bids. Three out of 90\. That’s a pretty lame batting average, about what Rafael Palmeiro’s going to hit now that he’s off the juice.

A committee made up of staff from the Annenberg Foundation, providers of grant money for the rehab, and from the city’s environmental and public works management, and community and cultural services — hardly a jury of design peers — selected the winning bid. Their choice was quickly rubber stamped by the City Council, with only Bobby Shriver objecting to the meager options.

Fortunately, the architect on the chosen team is Fred Fisher and Partners, an accomplished local firm, so we may get lucky: this grievously defective means for picking a designer may yet yield a soul-stirring structure. But for such a high-profile project shouldn’t we have had a choice of one of many top notch architects?

By way of contrast, let’s look at how the Arts Commission’s procedures strive to single out community artists who will “produce work of the highest quality and public benefit.” Selection panels are formed of “individuals who have a background or professional expertise in the arts.” Panelists are paid for their work and, to provide a diversity of tastes in a subjective process, can serve only once every two years. Likewise, artists who have been commissioned within three years are ineligible for new projects to ensure “a diverse collection that is representative of the wealth of aesthetic and cultural options.” It’s a sensible approach, one ignored by City Hall when the same people chose the same firm for the Civic Center Plan and the downtown design guidelines, and the same architect for the new library and Civic Center garage.

Finally, the Arts Commission acknowledges that RFPs are “not an appropriate selection process for projects where a design team approach is desired. Further, it is important to note that few established artists will respond to an open RFP.” Instead, a competition among artists “is particularly appropriate in the case of complex projects where a limited number of artists may be capable of successfully competing.”

Now we can argue until we’re blue in the face about whether or not architecture is art, but certainly the two have one thing in common: We’ve got to look at the results for the next 30 years or more. Wouldn’t it make sense to choose public architects in the same way we select public artists: a competition judged by professional colleagues?

How would such a competition ideally work? It would be internationally publicized in the right places, such as professional newsletters and periodicals. It would be open to all comers rather than by discretionary invitation. It would be a blind competition, with design schemes reviewed without names attached, to eliminate any favoritism. And it would be judged by a panel of prestigious practicing architects and academics, compensated appropriately for their time.

Yes, these competitions might cost more than the RFP process, but the public benefits of great design are worth the expense. Sadly, however, City Hall is in the midst of a massive makeover of its properties and most of the opportunities for transcendent public architecture have been missed.

All that’s left is the housing development called “The Village” in the Civic Center, where once again the RFP approach has narrowed the choices down to three teams, only one of which is composed of architects of any repute.

Perhaps it’s not too late to start over with the Village and try an international competition to seek the best possible design. I might not mourn the old RAND building so much if I thought that just once City Hall could build something great in aged building’s place. (Ted Winterer is a writer who lives in Ocean Park. He)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 19, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/081905.pdf?ref=smdp.com)