> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Coastal cities should appoint their own reps
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/coastal-cities-should-appoint-their-own-reps/
- Published: 2003-01-04T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T22:57:25.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Kevin Feldman*

This week’s unanimous ruling by the California Court of Appeals, upholding a previous decision that California’s Coastal Act violates the separation-of-powers doctrine, came as a surprise to many thoughtful observers. The Coastal Act has withstood nearly three decades of various challenges and retains both a popular and laudable goal — the protection of California’s 1,150-mile coastline for the benefit of all citizens.

In striking down the Coastal Act, the court reached several common sense conclusions: First, the Coastal Commission, through its various functions, for example, issuing permits, promulgating development regulations, etc., is engaged in “executive” activities. Second, there is no doubt that the legislature has control of the commission, since it appoints eight of the 12 members (the governor appoints the other four) and can remove them at will. Third, the California constitution requires the separation of powers between the different branches of government.

In language and reasoning that could have been drawn from a 12th grade civics lesson about the proper division of governmental responsibilities, the appellate court reached the obvious conclusion that the appointment process in the Coastal Act is flawed. Looking back, the real surprise isn’t the ruling, but how it has taken so long to arrive. Whether by its popular public goals, a lack of precise legal challenges or just sheer luck, the Coastal Act has survived until now relatively intact since it was enacted in 1976.

It doesn’t mean that the Coastal Commission has operated for all these years without controversy. The nature of the commission’s work, for example, balancing public coastline access with individual property rights, will always prove controversial, but the current appointment process has not helped matters. Indeed, there is a long and sordid history of wealthy political contributors lobbying individual legislators and the governor for approval of controversial coastal building permits.

In recent years, the commission also has found itself at odds with whole communities, as with the contentious debate to produce a “local coastal plan” for the city of Malibu. Earlier this year the commission approved a controversial plan that would impose a set of citywide local planning rules.

In a bizarre twist, the commission’s plan, while limiting many small-scale residential permits, may also encourage some large-scale commercial development. With many local residents unhappy with the plan and the process that produced it, voters are demanding a local referendum. The city has launched a challenge to the plan in court and through vocal lobbying, Sara Wan, the embattled Chair of the Coastal Commission has been forced to step down.

Needless to say there is some room for improvement in the commission’s functioning and a new appointment process is a good place to start. Several simple remedies to the constitutional deficiencies are already being discussed in Sacramento.

State Senator Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica) has said she will introduce a bill to give coastal commissioners fixed terms, thereby removing the legislature’s ability to remove its appointees “at will,” which is a practice the courts have reasonably found makes the Coastal Commission no more than a handmaiden to the will of powerful legislators.

Others have suggested longer and staggered terms, perhaps four-year appointments and increasing the number of appointments from the governor to make the Coastal Commission more like other commissions in the executive branch. Both of these are good ideas.

The Legislature often devises appointment schemes to balance the governor’s power with its own, but there are other ways to balance the governor’s appointments that would help address concerns about local accountability. One idea would be to balance the governor’s appointments with local appointments from coastal cities and/or counties. There is already a process the Legislature uses to rotate some appointments among elected city representatives from different regions, so why not delegate those appointments to the coastal counties and cities? This may require increasing the size of the commission to ensure proper representation across the state, which would also be a good outcome.

Some special interests will likely oppose any diffusion of appointment power to local communities, especially if it requires increasing the size of the commission. Under a more locally accountable Coastal Commission, special interest lobbying, which is now highly concentrated in Sacramento, would become much more difficult. The public would be better served, however, by a commission that is both accountable to state citizens as a whole (through the governor’s appointments), as well as local coastal communities.

Kevin Feldman is a public policy and financial consultant in Los Angeles. He via e-mail:

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 4, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/010403.pdf?ref=smdp.com)