> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Courage under fire was Rather’s downfall
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/courage-under-fire-was-rathers-downfall/
- Published: 2005-03-16T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:42:05.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

*By (Ed Silverstein)*

On March 9, after 24 years, Dan Rather gave his last broadcast as anchor of the CBS Evening News. The reason for his leaving is credited to a well-publicized lapse of judgment, but in truth, he is the latest victim of a well-organized smear campaign by ultra-right conservatives. His supposed crime: being a liberal.

These are the same people who, when Rather was covering the civil rights movement, were plotting against the “nigger-lovers” between rounds at their whites-only golf course. When he was dodging bullets in Vietnam, a war even its architects have disowned, these white-glove draft dodgers were calling for esca-lations behind the safety of their corporate desks. When Rather asked the tough questions of a president who had misused, corrupted and disgraced his office, it was Rather, not Richard Nixon, they railed against as un-American. And it is Rather, the liberal, who is unpatriotic for reporting on widespread torture of prisoners by our soldiers and the despicable justifications from the administration of a president who claims to be compassionate.

Never mind that none of these stories have anything to do with liberal or conservative, so much as what is reasonable and just. According to this rabid pack of foaming neo-cons, a liberal is anyone who doesn’t agree with their narrow-minded, hate-filled, hypocritical, cynical, self-serving view of the world, regardless of how immoral, unjustifiable or ridiculous.

They are thugs, who assassinate reputations under the guise of well-funded cover groups such as the Media Research Center. But don’t let names fool you. Unlike the unbiased Pew Research Center and FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy In Reporting), these are ultra-conservative financed hate groups, who, along with the ultra-right blight of bloggers, have a specific agenda and absolutely no scruples on how they achieve it.

Not all the blame goes to this pack of rich, robber barons and their brown-nosed sycophants. They would be impotent without the Brutus-like treachery of the invertebrate mangers of the mainstream media who have responded to the disingenuous accusations of bias by bending over so far backwards that the only thing they are capable of doing is kissing the right wing of their own buttocks.

But probably the lion’s share of blame should go to Rather’s own jelly-kneed compatriots who have traded their journalistic integrity for a few crumbs of political access. In fairness, Rather, or more likely, his producer, was negligent in checking the authenticity of a memo that was used as a key piece of evidence to show that our self-named “War President” had not fulfilled his own military obligations. More damning was Rather’s continued defense of the document when it became increasingly evident that is was a fraud. But in the end, it was simply a mistake … sort of. Because, fraudulent memo not withstanding, the story about the President was true.

But the piranha pack ignored the fresh blood of the Pentagon’s equivocating, obstruction and select-document shredding, as well as presidential denials so unctuous that they invoke images of eels writhing in a barrel of Dubai sweet crude. Instead, like a pack of alchemists celebrating the secret of turning gold into lead, they engaged in an atavistic feeding frenzy against one of their own.

But even as they masquerade their jealousy as righteous indignation, somehow they are able to ignore the elephant in the room, even though it has just crapped on the carpet.

Where is the indignation over FOX’s Brit Hume, a pundit affecting the personage of an anchor, whose slanted character assassination is achieved, not with fake memos, but with scurrilous innuendo? Why have they not condemned the Swift Boat Commanders and its whelp, USA Next, as dishonest Republican propagandists rather than expending their energy providing them legitimacy by uncovering a couple of minor truths in a cesspool of lies.

And if the media has such a liberal bias, where are the 20 news cycles devoted to condemning a President who peddles phony misinformation dressed up as legitimate news stories, pays commentators to bolster his unsupportable positions, gives access to a gay escort pretending to be reporter who is nothing more than a prostitute for Republicans while withholding access to any journalist with the guts to do their job?

Courage. It is the word Dan Rather used to sign off with on his final broadcast. Hopefully, his fellow journalists were listening. Because unless they find their courage, misled Americans will vote without a brain and we will continue to have leaders without a heart.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 16, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/031605.pdf?ref=smdp.com)