> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Cuts go deep at district
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/cuts-go-deep-at-district/
- Published: 2002-06-19T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T00:21:10.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*LETTERS*

*By Zina Josephs Santa Monica*

Editor: (This letter was originally addressed to the Santa Monica City Council.) I realize that you are in a difficult position at the moment in trying to balance the city’s budget for 2002-2003\. The school district is also in a difficult position. In fact, school districts across the state and the nation are in a difficult position this year because of economic conditions that are beyond the control of local school boards. The question for us to consider is how reduced funding from the state of California will affect SMMUSD students.

The answer is, unfortunately, that the school district will not be able to implement improvements, rather it will have to reduce or eliminate programs districtwide.

After reviewing the list of proposed SMMUSD budget reductions for 2002-2003, I’d like to describe for you the effect some of these reductions will have on the one area I know a little bit about, fine arts. 1\. Eliminate Elementary Extra-Duty Units (pay for work beyond the regular school day). This would eliminate the all-district elementary honor orchestra for the Stairway of the Stars concerts, which involves Saturday auditions, 10 weekly afterschool 3-hour rehearsals, and two evening concerts. (One of the benefits of the Stairway dress rehearsal and concerts is that the elementary music students have an opportunity to hear the middle and high school choirs, orchestras, bands, and jazz bands perform several times. This gives them an aural picture of what a more advanced ensemble sounds like and gives them something to aspire to. It is also a very inspiring experience for their parents, and those parents tend to become active fundraisers for the districtwide music program.) 2\. Reduce Middle School Extra-Duty Units by 40 percent. This would also affect Stairway rehearsals and regular after-school rehearsals. Teachers with large ensembles usually hold after-school small-group “sectional” rehearsals in order to give students more individualized attention and instruction.

This is especially important for students whose families cannot afford private lessons. 3\. Reduce High School Extra-Duty Units by 10 percent. This would affect Stairway, after-school sectional rehearsals, and Marching Band. Band instructors work all the football games, and on band tournament days, they work from 5 a.m. on Saturday to 1 a.m. or 2 a.m. on Sunday. 4\. Reduce Instructional Aide Spending by 50 percent. This would affect music aides at middle and high school levels. At the middle schools, for example, the aides can help supervise during emergency situations in classes of up to 90 students. They help teachers use class time more efficiently by leading small-group sectional rehearsals which focus on problems specific to a particular instrument. This is especially helpful for students whose families cannot afford private music lessons. When instruments need adjustment or repair during class, aides can assist students without interrupting the rehearsal. Without an aide, 89 students would sit and wait while the teacher replaced a broken string or unstuck a jammed valve for the 90th student. 5\. Eliminate Transportation Funding for Athletics and Music. This would affect Stairway, Marching Band participation in football games and band tournaments, orchestra and band participation in the annual Southern California Band and Orchestra Association adjudicated festivals, choir participation in Southern California Vocal Association adjudicated festivals, and other trips in which students either perform or attend performances. It would wipe out the entire transportation budget for the Samohi Music Department. Marching Band parents are already raising $70,000 a year, so either they would have to raise an additional $24,500 next year, or else individual band students would have to pay a transportation fee of $170, thereby making it impossible for students from low-income families to participate in Marching Band. 6\. Reduce the Fine Arts Coordinator Position to a Half-Time Position. A recipe for disaster. 7\. 20-25 percent Reduction in Instructional Supply Budgets. Samohi art teachers will receive only $160 per class per semester next year, or about 30 cents per student per week for art supplies. The Samohi music department instructional supply budget has been cut by 25 percent. $6,000 for a department with 828 students means $7.25 per student per year for buying new music, purchasing supplies such as clarinet reeds and cello strings, and repairing and replacing instruments. (A new tuba costs at least $3,000.) The Samohi fall plays and spring musicals really have no supply budget to cut. I believe that the drama teacher, Dr. Ford, has to pay for needed materials out of his own pocket. The Lincoln art department is also facing a 20 percent cut in its instructional supply budget, down to $160 per class per year, or about 15 cents per student per week for art supplies.

Conclusion: If all of these reductions are adopted, a) it will be increasingly difficult for secondary art teachers to teach to the district, state, and national standards for visual arts instruction, b) the 53-year-old tradition of the annual SMMUSD Stairway of the Stars concert, featuring elementary through high school music students, may come to an end, and c) the oldest marching band in the State of California, the Samohi Viking Marching Band, for lack of transportation, may be unable to compete in tournaments or play for football games. In other words, there will be no Marching Band to represent Samohi, SMMUSD, and the City of Santa Monica.

Please keep in mind that cuts in education funding often end up affecting the students who can afford it least — those whose parents cannot afford to buy them extra supplies or pay transportation fees, those who need more individual attention or individualized instruction, those most in danger of falling behind, failing, or dropping out.

In a more perfect world, perhaps city governments would not be asked to help school districts. But in a more perfect world, school districts would have an adequate, steady, dependable source of funding and could do long-range financial planning, something that has become an impossibility in California since Prop 13.

It is not the children’s fault that power companies manipulated the market in California. It is not the children’s fault that the 9/11 tragedy occurred and caused a nationwide economic downturn. However, it is our responsibility, the responsibility of the adults, to provide the very best education for each and every child, no matter what else is going on in the world.

Please consider increasing the city’s ongoing annual contribution to the school district by $2 million so that reductions in these instructional programs can be avoided. Please consider the children.

SMMUSD needs your help. This year we are facing a shortfall well in excess of $2 million. Projections show that in three short years, this deficit will be very close to $6 million.

As an active music education advocate, I am particularly concerned about those proposed district budget cuts that would impact our music program; but neither do I want to see fewer nurses, classroom aides, or a diminished participation in athletic competitions. Given the current international climate, a reduction in campus security is frightening.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 19, 2002.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/061902.pdf?ref=smdp.com)