> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Deadly duel cheated us all
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/deadly-duel-cheated-us-all/
- Published: 2004-07-10T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:20:45.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D*

It was a hazy mid-summer morning. It was early. Vice President Dick Cheney, having recently been replaced by President Bush with Sen. John McCain on the Republican ticket, stood anxiously on a hill on the New Jersey side of the Hudson staring at New York. He was waiting.

Waiting for the man whose very presence reminded people that the Democrats were better stewards of the economy than were the Republicans. One thought bothered him more than most: Why didn’t the tax cuts create more jobs? Supply-side economics couldn’t be wrong. If the economy were stronger, he thought, I’d still be on the ticket — I’d still be relevant.

Former Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin appeared from around the bend. Behind him another man followed, carrying a sleek wooden case. It held two pistols. A man, who had been waiting silently with Cheney, approached the man with the case. He opened the case, removed the pistols, loaded them, and handed one to Cheney and one to Rubin. Each man then took a few steps away from the other and turned back around.

The man with the case, breaking the morning’s silence, yelled: “Present.” Shots rang out. Rubin fell to the ground. Cheney dropped the pistol and left.

The date was July 11, 2004\. If this scenario seems improbable, think again. It’s very nearly what occurred two hundred years ago tomorrow — July 11, 1804\. Two prominent men, Vice President Aaron Burr and First Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton, engaged in a duel on the bluffs at Weehawken, New Jersey. The affair of honor left Hamilton mortally wounded and Burr forever ruined.

The reasons for the interview are vague. Hamilton and Burr had long been political rivals, as Burr had aligned himself with both the Federalists (Hamilton’s party) and the Republicans (Jefferson’s party) as suited best his needs. Despite this, Hamilton and Burr had on many occasions collaborated professionally on legal cases and they were personally cordial, dining at each other’s homes and socializing together among Manhattan’s elites.

Though it was no secret that in the tied election of 1800, Hamilton had helped Thomas Jefferson (his despised philosophical rival) ascend the presidency over Burr, this was an insufficient charge for a duel. Duels were not supposed to be fought over politics. While Hamilton may have rubbed salt in Burr’s wounds by campaigning on behalf of Morgan Lewis over him for Governor of New York in 1804 (once Burr had lost favor as the vice president, the Republicans had chosen George Clinton to run with Jefferson), politics was politics. Duels were personal, not political.

Duels were the way a “gentleman” could defend his reputation against libelous remarks — untrue, character assassinations — honorably. Lawsuits claiming libel were not sufficiently becoming of elites. Legal action revealed cowardice.

The correspondence took place in late June of 1804 and began with Burr. He charged Hamilton with maligning his character. Burr had a letter from Dr. Charles Cooper, who had heard Hamilton criticizing Burr at a dinner party. Burr wanted Hamilton to either acknowledge or deny the incident. Burr’s charge turned on a phrase, “still more despicable,” where Burr explained that, if what had been written was not the worst then clearly Hamilton must owe him an apology. Hamilton, who was both mystified and annoyed by Burr’s letter, infuriated Burr with his answer. He neither affirmed nor denied the incident, and he wrote back that the charge was not specific enough for him to comment on. Their correspondence quickly spiraled out of control. Within days, the two men had agreed to meet at Weehawken. Within a month, Hamilton was dead and Burr was on the run, having to leave New York because he was now the prime suspect in a murder trial.

One of the more interesting parts of this duel is not Hamilton’s death, but instead his life.

It was extraordinary. His accomplishments were varied and numerous, from establishing the nation’s credit and system of finance to creating and stabilizing the institutional precepts of our national government. He argued the case that became the basis of our country’s libel law and he founded what has developed into the Coast Guard. Hamilton not only helped build a strong military run by civilians, but he also liberalized trade, supported abolition, and believed that society should be based on a meritocracy. He fought tirelessly to keep the country together, defending the Constitution, working to build “a more perfect union.” He had public character of the kind we rarely see today. He turned down offers to make money time and again, citing his public role and the possible perceived conflicts of interests, if he were to privately profit from his positions.

While he was not a saint — he engaged in an extramarital affair that turned into a scandal and he regularly attacked his political opponents with venomous fervor — it also was clear that he loved his wife and that he passionately believed in the causes he fought for.

One can’t help but wonder, what would have happened had he lived past 49? His wife, Elizabeth (Betsey or Eliza to him), lived until she was 97\. She died in 1854\. What would Alexander have accomplished had he been with us 50 more years?

In this year of Hamilton’s death, several commemorative events are taking place to celebrate his life and to ponder this question. Tomorrow, more than 600 participants and scholars will gather in Weehawken to witness a reenactment of the duel and to discuss Hamilton’s legacy (http://duel2004.weehawkenhistory.org/e vents.php). Beginning in September, the Gilder Lehrman Institute (http://www.gilderlehrman.org/) and the New York Historical Society (http://www.alexanderhamiltonexhibi-tion.org/) are launching an exhibition on Alexander Hamilton, “The Man Who Made Modern America,” that will travel across the country for six months.

As the 200th anniversary of Hamilton’s death passes and the presidential election of 2004 approaches, we once again are reminded of the choices before us. “A more perfect union” is not beyond our reach. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is an education policy consultant and a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for Social Science Research. She)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 10, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/071004.pdf?ref=smdp.com)