> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Election coverage: All the screech that’s fit to print
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/election-coverage-all-the-screech-thats-fit-to-print/
- Published: 2004-01-28T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:08:51.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Beth Solomon*

The mainstream media is hot on the trail of the most important story of the election season. That would be... the Iraq war? No. A grassroots liberal resurgence? Guess again. The main story, still on page one in the New York Times six days after it happened, is Howard Dean’s Iowa concession speech, a.k.a. “The Screech.”

It’s great that the media has made this the main event of the election — I mean, brought it to our attention. Because it brings up a lot of other things about Howard Dean that the media don’t like — I mean, need to be reported.

Diane Sawyer got an exclusive on-the-couch session with Howard and Judy Dean the night after the screech. A top crack reporter who once served in the Nixon White House, Sawyer honed right in on the fact that Howie gave Judy a rhododendron for her 50th birthday. Not exactly roses and chocolates, Sawyer pointed out.

“What I always do for my birthday, which is right around Mother’s Day, we have a combined celebration and we do a family bike ride,” Judy Dean said softly. “I’m not a very ‘thing’ person. I mean, I have everything I want, pretty much.”

Now, how weird is that? The woman is not focused on filling out her wardrobe or filling up her jewelry box. Sawyer raised her eyebrows with an apt combination of ridicule and disdain. “Are you, like, communists?” she might have asked. It’s great when journalists remind us of the values we should all share. Judy, what are you thinking?

“I don’t really care too much what I wear,” she went on to say. Obviously this campaign is DOA.

ABC’s Peter Jennings and Ted Koppel reminded viewers several times that Dean’s screech had derailed his candidacy during a televised debate they hosted the following night in New Hampshire. Isn’t it good when reporters tell us the facts? In the same broadcast, Fox’s Brit Hume quickly zeroed in on Dean’s statement that “I lead with my heart, not with my head.” Hume pointed out the danger, if not pure wackiness, of such a statement. He does have a point. What if the country had leaders that aggressively pursued peace, generosity and compassion? It would be a catastrophe for the greed, violence and hate that currently reign. Thanks, Brit!

Alessandra Stanley, a staff writer at the New York Times, reported that the screech was “ferocious, almost maniacal.” She called Dean “scary.” That was-n’t opinion, it was straight news, according to the Times. That’s what they mean by, “All the News That’s Fit to Print.”

But the week’s daily coverage turned out to be just a warm-up for the weekend reporters, who get a chance to sit back, get some perspective, and give us more facts — the ones that really matter. For instance, Chris Matthews, host of a few cable and network shows, called the screech a “screaming fit” that had “metastasized.”

NBC’s Campbell Brown agreed with him and restated that Dean’s candidacy was over. “It confirmed the worst fears people have about him.” Fears instilled by whom exactly? Joe Klein of Time Magazine told the other panelists that Dean’s behavior was that of a “recovering addict.” The other guests looked perplexed. This is what can happen when there are so many facts to consider.

The Los Angeles Times said Dean’s “raucous Iowa concession speech continued to echo in New Hampshire.” Honestly, the reporters heard an echo. “Can you hear me Chris Matthews, Chris Matthews, Chris Matthews?”

But the same reporters also allowed that some people thought the media were making too much of the screech. “I think they exploited this, to be honest with you,” a retired school administrator at the Londonderry, N.H. Lion’s Club told the Times.

But what do voters know? A precious few of them could have heard that Dean’s speech thanked his 1,500 young supporters in Iowa for getting involved in politics. And that voter turnout among people under 30 quadrupled in Iowa from the last presidential election. Dean said he’s seen nothing like it since the 1960s. And he pointed out that the kids are right to get involved, because they know the environment is getting destroyed, jobs are evaporating, and their futures are being hocked for massive tax cuts for the country’s wealthy.

“We’re going to fight until this country becomes a place where we’ll put more money into small children and their families than we put into prisons,” Dean said. He promised to stand up for “what Harry Truman put in the 1948 Democratic party platform: Health care for everybody.”

But let’s not get lost in some abstract discussion of what we stand for or where to lead the country. Let’s get back to the screech, I mean, the news. (Beth Solomon is a Left Coast writer reachable at).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 28, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/012804.pdf?ref=smdp.com)