> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Facts and clichés reveal truth on immigration issue
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/facts-and-clich-s-reveal-truth-on-immigration-issue/
- Published: 2004-06-07T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:12:34.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By CAROLE ORLIN*

It’s difficult to live in a state like California, where the growth surge has been and continues to be staggering, and not be aware of a very complex and sensitive issue: Immigration.

Whether it is the daily political debate in Sacramento that continues to simmer over illegal alien driver licenses or being confronted in the movie theater with Sergio Arau’s current “mockumentary” entitled “A Day Without a Mexican,” we continue to be challenged with assessing the extent of the link between immigration and the state’s accelerating and unsustainable growth.

We can all readily see that there are too many people with too few resources. We can all sense that our quality of life, from Santa Monica to Sacramento, is directly impacted by overpopulation: Traffic congestion, air pollution, water and energy demands, housing affordabili-ty, school overcrowding, an overburdened health care system... It seems that political correctness has caused our decision-makers to fail to act when it comes to putting a halt to a growing population where part of the solution involves reducing immigration. In my attempt to become a better-informed citizen, I decided to look at some recent studies that: (a.) look at our population numbers and see where the statistics lead us; and (b.) look at some interesting clichés to see whether there is support for a valid challenge.

Migrating to California from the East Coast nearly four years ago, I decided it was time to do some research and discover how much I didn’t know about California’s ever-increasing population. The most intriguing data that I reviewed was compiled by a non-profit corporation in Santa Barbara: Californians for Population Stabilization (CAPS). Two recent studies are set forth based on information from the California Department of Finance and from the Census Bureau, the former INS — now the Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services — and from research on domestic migration.

Dr. Leon Bouvier, a demographer, using state figures alone concludes: ■ Immigration is responsible directly and indirectly for 98 percent of California’s increasing population. ■ Direct immigration was responsible for 57 percent of California’s growth from 1990-2000, with the rest coming from births to foreign-born women. ■ California made its largest population jump in history, 13 percent, in the 1990s, adding 4,208,000 people (more than the total population of Ireland). ■ In the slightly more than two-year period from April, 2000, to July, 2002, California’s population increased by 1,244,385\. ■ If we continue this 1.74 percent growth each year, the state will double its population in 40 years.

Dick Schneider, environmental consultant, found: ■ By combining state and federal sources and independent research that 100 percent of California’s growth was the result of immigration and immigrant births, and that migration from other states was no longer a factor in California’s present size. ■ The contribution of immigration is actually larger than reported by the state of California, because the Census Bureau admitted undercounts of both legal and illegal immigrants. ■ This factored in out-migration by both native and the foreign born moving to other states. The reason that immigration accounts for 100 percent of California’s growth is partly because the native born population only increased by 2 percent over the decade, because of so many native-born residents leaving the state.

Richard Lamm, former Governor of Colorado and executive director of the Public Policy Institute at the University of Denver, has recently written about clichés.

Gov. Lamm addresses one of the great-est challenges to public policy, which is “knowing when and how to change a successful policy that has grown obsolete. Very few policies are immortal. Time is a kaleidoscope presenting policy makers with an ever-changing pattern. Yet the clichés from one era linger in our minds and public dialogue as if they were written in stone. Too often we confuse temporary success with universal wisdom. In (his) experience almost inevitably today’s solutions become tomorrow’s problems.”

He used mass immigration (not specifically California’s) as an example. While acknowledging that immigration has been good for America, he said we are no longer the nation of 65 million people that we were in the 1880s when we received the Statue of Liberty. Now we are a nation of over 290 million. “What other policy applicable in the 1880s is still applicable today?”

Another cliché — “Immigrants take jobs that Americans won’t do” — is challenged as a cliché that has “now become a job destroying and wage lowering philosophy where employers use both unskilled and increasingly skilled immigrants to hold down wages and obtain cheap labor at the expense of American workers.”

A cliché that especially angers Gov. Lamm is the suggestion that all discussion of immigration is racist. “(E)very immigrant-receiving country in the world has not only the right but also the duty to discuss and decide how many immigrants, which immigrants, and by what rules such decisions are to be enforced. It would be public policy malpractice not to debate and discuss such an important topic.”

Gov. Lamm highlights the danger of clichés and sees them as the enemy of thought. Quoting from the physicist Niels Bohr: “‘The opposite of a true statement is a false statement, the opposite of a great truth is often another great truth.’ Of course immigration has been good for America, but mass immigration during the Twenty-first Century brings far more liabilities than assets.”

There is nothing more I can add to this. All I can say is knowledge is power. (To reach Carole, ).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 7, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/060704.pdf?ref=smdp.com)