> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Fighting to sustain our sustainability
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/fighting-to-sustain-our-sustainability-editor/
- Published: 2003-10-24T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T03:07:34.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

In 1994, the City of Santa Monica adopted a sustainable city program designed to create a “more sustainable way of life,” both locally and globally. Basically, the idea is to make Santa Monica a city that can work now and in the future by making choices today that favor the natural environment when possible.

Included in the program’s guiding principles is this: “City decision-making will be guided by a mandate to maximize environmental benefits and reduce or eliminate negative environmental impacts.”

One wonders whether Santa Monica’s Sustainable City Program is really a “mandate” or not, because in case after case recommendations are made by city staff and decisions are made by the City Council, that seem to conflict with the Sustainable City Program’s principles. Here are some examples from the recent past: August, 2003: City staff recommends the expansion of the city’s garbage transfer facility at a cost of roughly $8 million. The facility would lose money unless an additional 200 tons of trash were brought into Santa Monica (or unless Santa Monicans were forced to pay higher trash collection rates).

That’s interesting. Why would we want to bring 200 more tons of trash into Santa Monica?

According to the staff report, Santa Monica generates, on average, 423 tons of trash each day, so 200 more tons translates to 4 percent more trash — and 47 percent more truck trips, and 47 percent more associated pollution. That’s significant. Wouldn’t it be more “sustainable” to reduce the amount of trash we’re generating as Santa Monicans, without having to worry about such reductions being at odds with the city staff’s goals? Wouldn’t it be more “sustainable” to work to reduce the amount of trash in general — in Santa Monica and in neighboring cities — instead of building in additional trash-handling capacity? And why would we want to increase the number of garbage truck trips into our town (or any), especially when the off ramp at Cloverfield Boulevard — the ramp closest to the transfer facility’s location — is already so congested as to cause traffic to back up on Interstate 10 for more than a mile on a daily basis? It is to the City Council’s credit that they rejected this proposal, but gee, can’t we get the city staff on board too?

August, 2003: City staff recommends leaving one side of the 1800 block of Ninth Street (nearly two-thirds of the block’s on-street parking spaces) unprotected in a sea of otherwise permit-only blocks. According to the staff report “many of the non-residential parkers involved were Santa Monica High School students...,” which puts staff’s recommendation squarely at odds with this guiding principle from the Santa Monica Sustainable City program: “Individual citizens, community-based groups and businesses must be aware of their impacts on the environment, must take responsibility for reducing or eliminating those impacts, and must take an active part in community efforts to address environmental concerns. The city will therefore be a leader in the creation and sponsorship of environmental education opportunities in cooperation with schools, colleges and other organizations in the community.”

Staff’s recommendation doesn’t show leadership in environmental education.

Rather, it encourages high school students to drive to school when — according to the Sustainable City guidelines — it ought to discourage the practice. Staff’s recommendation to leave one side of the street unprotected is notable in that it is contrary not only to the Sustainable City guidelines, but to the city’s municipal code and the residents’ stated wishes as well. Increased traffic, increased pollution, increased reliance on automobiles and a missed opportunity to teach our young people a lesson in sus-tainability, all in one recommendation. (As of this writing, staff has not provided a rationale for its recommendation.) October, 2003: City staff recommends creation of “Airport Park” at Santa Monica Airport. This would seem to be rather “sustainable,” yet the devil is in the details. When the park is built, Santa Monica College’s remote parking lot (a model of sus-tainability, providing free parking at the airport and free shuttle service to the campus) will be lost, causing (according to the final environmental impact report) “unavoidable adverse impacts” (that is, an increased number of cars) in neighborhoods as far away as Lincoln and Pico boulevards with “no feasible mitigation measures.” And the

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 24, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/102403.pdf?ref=smdp.com)