> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Finding Thanksgiving at your table this week
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/finding-thanksgiving-at-your-table-this-week/
- Published: 2004-11-22T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:16:41.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By HIP TO BE SQUARE BY CAROLINE BODKIN*

In the wake of a terribly divisive presidential election, Thanksgiving might offer a way to become humble after your side won, or thankful even though your side lost.

In early November, we were told again and again that America is divided. Between the liberals and the conservatives, the red states and the blue states, Jesusland and Freedomland.

And we, like children, accepted the labels that were given to us. We picked sides. We became red or blue, liberal or conservative. Like we were nothing more than those descriptions. Like it was that simple.

If you were red, you were moral, you were faithful, you were pro-life and anti-big government. You were religious. You didn’t believe in gay marriage — in fact you believed it should be banned. You were intolerant and closed-minded. You had family values. You were comfortably in the right.

And if you were blue, then you were a free thinker. Tolerant of everyone and everything, including criminals and baby-killers. You lacked morals and hugged trees and would love to see condoms distributed in elementary schools. You were educated and cultured and concerned about what other nations thought of you. You believed you too had family values, and you too, knew you were right.

We declared our side was right, the other side was wrong. And the other side declared their side was right, and our side was wrong. And we rejected each other, and became indignant, and became self-important and eventually we were so polarized, our nation was, as predicted, split in two. And the two sides became such foreign entities that understanding each other was out of the question — let alone agreeing with each other. What could they possibly have in common?

And it was toxic. Limiting. Dangerous. The truth is, we are not a nation of Democrats or Republicans. We are a nation of individuals.

We — all of us — have values. We have beliefs. We have families, priorities, ambitions, incomes, challenges and personal histories. We have made mistakes. We have been successful. We want to be respected. We want safety and love. We do not want to be hateful. This is true about all of us. We all have these things in common, regardless of how we voted, or which side we chose.

And we will continue to have them in common, regardless of how the next four years go.

We are common humans. So now, in late November, whether we were victorious or defeated, we are all at a loss. How do we begin to understand the group we have pushed so far away?

This Thanksgiving, wherever you are, whomever you’re with, there’s a good chance you don’t all come from the same side of this divided nation. So take a minute to consider each person at your table. Create in your head a potential life story for them. Where they were born, what kind of parents they had. When they lost their virginity and with whom. What they studied in school, or if they weren’t able to go to school, then why not? What they get sad about, and whether or not it would make you sad too. Consider their humanity.

These are the things that define us. These are the things that give us our voice. These are the things, the details of life, that when considered thoughtfully, can help us understand each other.

They cannot be painted red or blue. They cannot be reduced.

We are common people. And the things we have in common are vastly more important than the things we let divide us.

That is what I am so very grateful for. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and should count her blessings more often. You can ).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 22, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/112204.pdf?ref=smdp.com)