> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Ghosts of budgets past: How we got in the mess we’re in
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/ghosts-of-budgets-past-how-we-got-in-the-mess-were-in/
- Published: 2004-03-26T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T04:04:10.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Sheila Kuehl*

(Editor’s note: This is the first in a series of articles by State Senator Sheila Kuehl, D-Santa Monica).

To be clear, the following is not designed to advocate. Rather than argue for a point of view, I wanted to create a place to provide information generally not accessible by most people. Every day in the Capitol, there are conversations, presentations, votes and endless discussions, all of which shed light on topics people ask me about every day.

The No. 1 topic I’m asked about is the budget.

I will try, in the first few pieces, to simplify how we got into what most people are calling “the budget mess,” how big the problem really is, several proposed solutions and the consequences, intended and unintended, of those proposed solutions, including the big bond (prop. 57) and balanced budget requirement (prop. 58) that were just adopted by the electorate.

As you read this, the Legislature and Governor Schwarzeneggger are attempting to deal not only with the current budget, but also with: The leftover results of prior budgets, brought forward as obligations; changes to the current year’s budget; the adoption of the next year’s budget and, often, with predictions about what decisions in the next budget will mean to future budgets.

The 2003-2004 budget totaled about $97.4 billion, including expenditures from bond funds, federal funds, special funds — those dedicated to a particular purpose, like fees — and the general fund, which is the aggregate, mostly, of our taxes. The 2004-5 budget is projected at about $97.2 billion.

If you count bond funds, however, and some costs required to be absorbed because some one-time savings we used in 2003-4 have expired, the new budget is more like $100.2 billion. $76.1 billion of that is general fund revenues and that amount has been seriously dropping since the tech “bubble” burst. This creates a problem for the state because we have a serious over-reliance on personal income taxes for state revenue.

HISTORY AND TAXES In 1977-78, about 5/12 of the general fund revenue came from property taxes, about 1/4 from sales and use taxes, about 1/6 from personal income taxes and 1/6 from all other taxes. By 2004-2005, after Prop. 13, tax reductions, tax credit legislation and other limitations, more than 1/4 of the revenue had to come from personal income, somewhat less than 1/4 from property taxes, a bit over 1/4 from sales and use taxes and almost 1/4 from all other. So, when personal income tanked in the state, so did the revenue side of the budget, and fairly suddenly.

HISTORY AND EXPENDITURES In 1962-3 almost 40 percent of the budget went to kindergarten through 12th grade, about 1/8 to higher education, less than 1/4 to health and human services, a tiny slice to corrections, almost 1/5 to transportation and a little less than 1/4 to “other.” By 2002-03, corrections was twice as big a slice of the pie, kindergarten through 12th grade was about the same, higher education was about the same, transportation had shrunk to more or less equal with corrections, and health and human services had grown to more than 1/4 of the budget. The growth in this latter category was due primarily to an unprecedented shrinkage in middle class jobs and more reliance by the working poor, whose numbers were growing significantly on services. I’m sure you read that Wal-Mart, for instance, pays so little, almost half of their employees qualify for Medical benefits, a state program to provide minimal healthcare for the working, indigent and disabled poor.

IN THE GOOD TIMES In 1998-99 through 2002-03, we gave back $3.7 billion in tax relief, spent $4.7 million on kindergarten through 12th grade education, $2.4 billion on higher education, $4.8 billion on health, $2.3 billion on social services and $2 billion on all other (resources, transportation, corrections, etc.). Expansions in programs were almost exclusively in education and healthcare for the poor but these were minimal as to each individual, primarily accomplished by allowing more children to be eligible for medical services and childcare. The population needing these services had also grown, including our senior population, which is poorer and more medically vulnerable.

IN THE BAD TIMES Employment recently plummeted in the higher paying job sectors by more than 20 percent, and, in the case of manufacturing jobs, by 25 percent. Suddenly, the revenues to the state from personal income taxes and capital gains were far less than expected. Since my colleagues in the Republican Party took an oath not to raise any taxes and, indeed, were threatened with a primary challenge if they even indicated they might consider it, the only way to balance this year’s (2003-04, passed last July) budget was through cutting programs.

The problem was made worse by the fact that the cuts in the vehicle license fees, which we had made during the good times, were supposed to be restored when the general revenues sank. Actually, the vehicle license fee, which funds local police and fire services, had never gone down. These fees were still set, as they had been for decades, at 2 percent of the value of your car. Since these fees go to local governments to fund police and fire services, we had simply voted to pay a portion of your vehicle license fee out of the general fund. This is called a “backfill.” Gov. Davis did not, therefore, “triple” the fee. His director of finance simply declared that there was nothing but borrowed money in the state coffers and that declaration, by law, triggered an end to the backfill. Result: You had to start paying your full vehicle license fee yourself.

CUTS The 2003-4 budget contained over $14 billion in cuts and when you consider the allocation of expenditures in the budget, you can see that most of them came from healthcare for the poor and higher education. We can’t cut the debt service that pays for past borrowing and bonds. We can’t cut the amount we’re supposed to put into certain healthcare and education programs because we would lose a far greater amount in federal funds. So it was bone and muscle, not fat, that got cut. Nevertheless, we cut.

WASTE AND FRAUD Interestingly enough, there wasn’t much. We had cut a great deal in the last three years. So when the current governor brought Donna Arduin from Florida to dig out “waste and fraud” in the state budget and therefore bring the current budget into balance, she huffed and puffed but couldn’t find any. Indeed, even in her last highly touted job in Florida, her suggestions for cuts had been almost exclusively in the area of schools and healthcare.

So? Restoration of the vehicle license fee backfill from the general fund (you think of it as a cut in your fee, we think of it as unbudgeted additional money out of the general fund for police and fire) meant that we were called upon to cut more than $2 billion extra out of this year’s budget (2003-2004). You’ve seen the results in school budgets, you may not have seen the local clinics closing, or cuts in health-care for the poor, but they’re also there. And, in bad economic times, the need for services for those affected by job loss, aging, etc., just grows.

Next time: What lies ahead: The 2004- 05 budget now under consideration and how we consider it. Future articles will address workers’ comp-proposed legislation, how it will be amended, current discussions and issues; the fallout of vehicle license fee decisions, up and down; gay marriage — what’s the real law about this issue here and in other states; the health-care in California — the problem, proposed solutions, buying drugs from Canada or not; the new Medicare drug benefit and its impact on seniors — what they have now and what to expect.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 26, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/032604.pdf?ref=smdp.com)