> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# GUEST COMMENTARY BY ELAN JOURNO Energy bill fails to electrify innovation
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/guest-commentary-by-elan-journo-energy-bill-fails-to-electrify-innovation/
- Published: 2005-08-03T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:27:49.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

Oh, happy days. Last week the energy bill was passed. This means, among other things, that another $11 billion of our taxes will be handed over to the oil and gas industry for domestic exploration. This is good news for my oil and gas investments, which are currently paying a mere 36 percent per year in highly tax-advantaged dividends.

Of course, our elected officials would like us to believe that such incentives are necessary to spur domestic energy production. Nothing could be further from the truth. With record oil prices, they can’t sink wells fast enough. So this bill is yet another example of our corrupted politicians, led by a nihilistic president, enriching their campaign contributors at our expense.

And what is really needed, namely a meaningful conservation program and a significant commitment to renewable energy, is glaringly absent from the bill.

For instance, where is the increase in gas mileage? The technology exists. But every time Congress tries to mandate better mileage — as they did in earlier versions of the energy bill — the auto industry screams that fuel efficiency will increase vehicle cost, which will hurt sales, which are already decimated due, in part, to the industries’ prior unwillingness to embrace energy efficient vehicles. Then their lobbyists move in, fill the campaign coffers of sympathetic politicians, i.e.; anyone up for reelection, and the provision is killed.

The sane solution is to take the unnecessary $11 billion from domestic oil and gas exploration and use it to provide rebates for fuel-efficient vehicles. The amount of the rebate should be awarded on a sliding scale. For example, buyers of vehicles getting more than 35 miles per gallon would receive $1,500; 40 miles per gallon, $2,000 and over 45 miles per gallon, $2,500\. Not only would those vehicles dramatically cut gas consumption but with increased popularity, the cost of the technology would be reduced, which would ultimately benefit all vehicles including gas guzzling SUVs.

Another issue that should be addressed is energy efficient homes. I am currently involved in a development in Montana. We would like to make it an Energy Star community, which means we would employ construction techniques and purchase appliances that reduce energy consumption by between 15 to 30 percent over standard construction. This will save the homeowner up to $500 per year and, for every three Energy Star homes built, it is the same as taking two cars off the road.

The problem is that Energy Star construction adds $3,500 or more to the cost of each home. And since Montana offers no tax incentives and awareness of the program remains low, it is virtually impossible to recoup any of this additional cost.

What is needed is for the federal government to provided tax incentives to buyers and builders for Energy Star homes and products. Energy consumption and emissions would be slashed and needed relief provided to overwhelmed energy grids.

One of the bill’s provisions that I do support is increasing funding for nuclear energy. As of now, it remains one of the only viable clean energy sources and many of the safety issues have been resolved. However, that is a temporary solution.

The only permanent fix to the energy crisis is a massive investment in renewable sources of energy. And while the bill does provide some funds for wind energy, it is not nearly enough.

Montana, for instance, is among the windiest states in the country. This, along with existing power distribution infrastructure and thousands of acres of undeveloped land, makes it ideal for massive wind farms. Of course the main hurdle to wind power has always been that it is only available when it is windy and storage technology is inefficient. The solution might lie in hydrogen.

To create hydrogen you need electricity. But using dirty power produced by carbon burning plants defeats the purpose. Wind power, on the other hand, offers a clean source of electricity. And hydrogen, in turn, could be stored and used to produce clean power during windless periods.

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger is promoting another innovative plan. It calls for installing $1 million solar panels on homes and other structures in California. This would produce as much energy as several new power plants, but without any of the public or environmental outcry. And increased panel purchases will spur research and development that will reduce the price and increase the efficiency ultimately making solar power a cost effective alternative.

If we embrace this painless combination of conservation and alternative energy, our environment will become cleaner and our health will improve. In addition, by eliminating our dependency on Mideast oil we would increase our security. And with oil prices already at record levels and energy demands in China, India and other Asian countries exploding, reducing our oil needs and creating low-cost renewable energy sources will position the U.S. to remain a preeminent economic power for the foreseeable future.

Of course such long-term fixes requires strong, insightful leaders who are willing to stand up to corporate interests for the good of all Americans …. Hmm.

I guess I better keep putting my money into oil and gas. (Ed Silverstein)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 3, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/080305.pdf?ref=smdp.com)