> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Lara M. Brown: Here's the thing about the Electoral College
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/heres-the-20040603/
- Published: 2004-06-03T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:09:27.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D*

“… A President of the United States … (shall) be elected as follows: Each state shall appoint … a number of electors, equal to the whole number of senators and representatives to which the state may be entitled in the Congress … The electors shall meet … and vote … The person having the greatest number of votes for president, shall be president, if such a number be a majority of the whole number of electors appointed …”

So reads Article II, Section 1 of the United States Constitution. Few decisions stirred as much debate at the Constitutional Convention in 1787 — delegates wrestled with the topic of how to select a president at least 20 times during that summer — and few passages in the final document confound politicians and the public the way the electoral college does today.

Many would like to scrap it in favor of a direct popular election, which they argue would allow for true democracy. Many believe that the 2000 presidential election result was illegitimate — not the Supreme Court decision, not the alleged voting irregularities, but the electoral college tally itself.

Four times in history candidates have won a majority of electors, yet failed to win a plurality of the popular vote, becoming president — Adams in 1824, Hayes in 1876, Harrison in 1888, and Bush in 2000\. Reformers assume that “if these instances have occurred, then something must be wrong.”

Imagine playing a basketball game. One team wins (go Lakers). A referee then tells you that you must replay the game, but free throw points don’t count. Would you assume the game’s result would be the same? That each team would finish with the same score, that either team would play as they had before, that they wouldn’t make adjustments? No.

Presidential candidates and the two major political parties design their strategies around one number: 270 — the number of electoral college votes needed to win the presidency. They don’t focus on winning the popular vote. If they had, they’d have played a different game.

Reformers also argue that a direct popular election would force the candidates to compete nationally, rather than in only a few states. It’s true that candidates would have national strategies, but what would this mean? They’d likely be in fewer places than they are now and the campaigns would be more expensive.

The electoral college system turns the presidential election into 50 statewide elections, rather than one national election. To win, you need to win enough states, so that when you add up all of their electoral college votes, they come to 270\. The system favors large states (more electoral votes) that are competitive (they could vote for either candidate). The more competitive the state, the more likely each candidate will spend resources trying to win the state’s electors. This year, states like California and Texas are ignored because they are considered “safe” for one candidate or the other, while 17 are in “play.”

If you change the rules, then each candidate would need around 52 million votes to win, assuming 50 percent of registered voters vote for president. Rather than ignoring “safe” states, candidates would ignore “safe” regions. Bush would ignore rural areas (Great Plains, South, and Mountain West) and conservative cities (Houston and Dallas), while Kerry would ignore most urban centers (Los Angeles, Boston and New York) and the progressive coastal towns (Eastern and Western seaboards).

The only places the candidates would allocate resources (travel time, advertising money, and grassroots campaigning) to would be the cities and suburbs that are fairly large and highly competitive. The “International Airport Tour” should be the title of this proposal because the candidates would likely be traveling to cities that are between 1 million and 4 million people and that recently — in the last 20 years — expanded their airports to include multiple international carriers (e.g., St. Louis, Phoenix, San Diego, Charlotte, NC, etc.).

Not incidentally, these cities have fairly expensive media markets, which means the cost of the campaigns would likely increase. To make matters worse, you probably wouldn’t see a candidate outside a large venue (possibly a stadium or ball-park), or on a commercial because all that would matter would be vote “volume” nationally.

HERE’S THE THING: Often zealots suggest reforms without analyzing the implications of their proposals. Nothing wreaks more havoc in our political system than ill-conceived laws passed with good intentions. Reform is necessary and important. Change can be positive. But don’t confuse change with progress.

Before endorsing ideas that just “sound good,” like more direct democracy, spend time understanding why things are the way they are. The electoral college has many benefits (see Hamilton’s cogent defense of it in the Federalist 68), and the practical drawbacks of a direct popular election should be enough to give one pause. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is an education policy consultant and a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for Social Science Research. She).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 3, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/060304.pdf?ref=smdp.com)