> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Letter: Reader gets the April Fools joke about the Chicago Ribs ad
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/historic-district-opposer-strikes-back/
- Published: 2002-04-03T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T00:13:24.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Tom Larmore*

Guest commentary by Tom Larmore

Barbara Schnitzler’s guest commentary on historical districts, although undoubtedly sincere, entirely misses the point (Daily Press, April 2, 2002). It is no secret that as a 27-year resident of Santa Monica and owner of a home listed in the city’s historic resources inventory as a potential structure of merit, I have concerns about the city’s landmarks ordinance. However, those concerns are not generated by any of the straw-man arguments contained in Ms. Schnitzler’s column.

The fundamental issue is one of the freedom of homeowners to determine for themselves, subject to generally applicable zoning laws, the nature of the home which they find suitable for their families. We all live in a society which imposes general development restrictions dealing with issues such as height, lot coverage and setbacks. But within those broad parameters, we assume that we will have the right to design, build or remodel our homes as we see fit. The landmarks ordinance substantially curtails that right because it gives power to an unelected body to determine, on a very microscopic level, whether we will be allowed to make those decisions for ourselves.

The essence of the landmarks ordinance is that a homeowner must be subject to detailed, time-consuming and expensive regulations with respect to the design of his or her home because others want it left substantially the way it is or at least want to decide how it can be changed. It’s absolutely remarkable to me that this loss of liberty isn’t immediately obvious and objectionable to everyone. Can anyone imagine telling Samuel or John Adams, Thomas Jefferson or James Madison that they were creating a country in which a homeowner could be prevented from building a new home in order to maintain an outdoor museum?

Ms. Schnitzler argues that historic structures are eligible to receive property tax discounts of up to 50 percent and that these discounts can be passed on to new buyers. This is a common, but entirely misleading, statement. Historic properties are taxed based upon their potential net income as rentals rather than upon sale prices. Therefore, if, like me, you have owned your home for many years, there will be no tax reduction for you. The fact that you can pass the benefits on to a buyer are of little comfort if all you want to do is remodel rather than sell. It seems odd to trumpet the merits of a “benefit” which you can achieve only when you leave Santa Monica.

Even this argument entirely misses the point. If there are real benefits available from historic designations, the owners should be made aware of them and be able to determine for themselves whether those benefits are sufficient to justify subjecting their properties to the landmarks commission. To attempt to justify the law based upon the supposed existence of benefits is yet another example of the government attempting to decide what is good for you rather than letting you make that decision.

Ms. Schnitzler also contends that property values increase rather than decrease in historic districts. If this is true, it is probably because most historic districts are created in older areas where homes have not been kept up and property values are declining. This is certainly not the case in any part of Santa Monica. Again, however, if the creation of such districts benefit property values, that is another argument which can be used to convince owners of appropriate properties to allow their homes to be so designated; it is not an argument in support of mandatory designation.

Ms. Schnitzler argues that the commission has no jurisdiction over interior improvements. While I believe that the commission is not interested in improvements which do not affect the exterior, the section she cites is precisely opposite to her point. Section 9.36.140 of the zoning code deals with situations in which the commission can issue a “certificate of appropriateness” for alterations to a landmark or a home in an historic district. Because the owner cannot obtain a permit for any alteration to such a home without commission approval, the commission obviously has jurisdiction over the proposed alteration; otherwise, why would the owner have to seek the approval? To say that the commission will grant the approval is quite a different statement than to say that no such approval is needed.

The problem with the manner in which the ordinance operates is illustrated by the commission’s recent denial of an application for a certificate of appropriateness by a homeowner in one of the existing historic districts to add a garage underneath the current home. Attending that hearing led to two important conclusions.

First, there were owners in the district who supported the application and others who opposed it and, like most city bodies, expressions of opinion by neighbors was quite important to the commission. What this leads to, and what was evident to me at the hearing, is that neighbors use this application as a forum to vent old grudges and raise irrelevant issues.

Second, the commission, at least in part, denied the application based on considerations which are not found in any part of the ordinance; in this case issues relating to parking and the “cultural history” of shared driveways. For those of us who might wish to believe Ms. Schnitzler’s analysis of the law, it is frightening to watch a homeowner’s plans go down the drain due to difficult neighbors and commissioners willing to base their decisions on irrelevant issues.

Ms. Schnitzler points out that before properties can be landmarked or historic districts can be created, there are a number of public hearings giving owners an opportunity to be heard. However, anyone who has watched the commission recently ignore the wishes of owners both north of Montana and in Sunset Park will agree that they would feel much more protected if the law required their approval.

Finally, Ms. Schnitzler gets to what I think is the heart of the issue. She states that many Santa Monica residents have been concerned “about the rapid pace of demolition of older homes” resulting in “mansionization” and the loss of “neighborhood character.” No doubt there are people with such feelings, particularly those who already live in large and recently remodeled homes.

Recently, the council adopted the “monster mansion” ordinance to deal with the scale of homes being built north of Montana and we may see such an ordinance created for Sunset Park as well somewhere in the future. While I support the imposition of generally applicable controls to keep new houses from overwhelming neighboring homes (and, in fact, supported the first such ordinance when I was on the planning commission almost 20 years ago), it is duplicitous to use the landmarks ordinance to attempt to further impair the property rights of homeowners.

I believe that people should be able to design and build their homes in a manner which suits them rather than in a manner decreed by others so long as they abide by generally applicable and reasonable development standards. I do not believe the government or my neighbors have the right to interfere with this very personal decision.

For this reason, I support the Homeowners Freedom of Choice Initiative which will allow for historic preservation on a voluntary basis rather than by government fiat. If the government response is that preservation will not occur unless it is mandatory, my point is more than proven.

(Tom Larmore is a property owner north of Montana and a property rights attorney.)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 3, 2002.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/040302.pdf?ref=smdp.com)