> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Intelligence failure for ages: It’s a Bush thing
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/intelligence-failure-for-ages-its-a-bush-thing/
- Published: 2004-04-14T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:53:25.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ed Silverstein*

Condeleeza Rice put on a remarkable display of semantic gymnastics during her testimony before the 9/11 commission. And though her molding of the facts to assign blame to others was little more than damage control, there is a kernel of truth. Admittedly, there were failures in each of the four most recent administrations. Yet, not all the failures were equal.

In his book “Against All Enemies,” Richard Clarke, the former terrorist czar, points out that President Ronald Reagan did not retaliate for the bombing in Beirut that killed 278 Marines. He even went against his own policy by negotiating — disastrously — with terrorists during the Iran-Contra scandal. President George H. W. Bush also failed to retaliate after Pan Am flight 103 was bombed.

Then, President Bill Clinton was elected. If the United States’ fight against terrorism had been as organized and as effective as the right wing media’s fight to disparage the Clinton Administration’s record on terrorism, there never would have been a 9/11.

When Clinton took office, there were no organized or comprehensive counter-terrorism policies. The threat had been underestimated by the previous two administrations and their lack of reprisals had emboldened both terrorists and the states that sponsored them.

Yet Clinton, with the help of staff members such as Clarke, identified terrorism as the primary post cold-war threat to our security. Far from being disengaged, the administration’s efforts resulted in quelling Iranian attacks against American interests. And in 1993, in retaliation for the attempted assassination of the first President Bush, Clinton ordered a cruise missile attack that destroyed Iraqi intelligence headquarters and so unnerved Saddam that from that point forward he was not involved in even a single attack against America.

His administration also uncovered the al Qaeda terrorist organization and identified its leaders, including Osama bin Laden. They dispelled the firmly held belief that such organizations required state sponsorship, and uncovered funding from quasi-religious and charitable organizations.

The Clinton administration worked diligently against al Qaeda and was able to prevent them from dominating Bosnia during the crisis in the Balkans. Clinton also ordered the assassination of bin Laden, yet, despite GOP myths, was never provided with sufficiently conclusive intelligence to launch an attack. And there is as much veracity to claims that Clinton ignored offers by the Yemeni or Sudanese governments to turn over bin Laden, as there was to rumors that Hillary murdered Vince Foster.

What is true is that Clinton, through his own relentless reading, identified the potential for terrorists to use chemical, biological or even nuclear weapons. He initiated programs to increase stocks of medical supplies and vaccines as well as detection equipment for nuclear material. Though undermined by Republican opposition, Clinton supported programs to provide jobs for Soviet scientists so that they would not be lured away by terrorist groups or regimes seeking to acquire weapons of mass destruction. And the list goes on.

Was there more that Clinton could have done? Sure. But remember, he was hobbled by unrelenting Republican attacks. Every military attack against terrorists abroad was undermined by accusations that they were politically motivated. And the military and intelligence communities were so risk adverse that they resisted any attack that utilized American personnel or assets.

In contrast, the Bush Administration was not working in a vacuum. There had already been numerous attacks against American interests. There was policy in place and plans for the future. The Bush staff was extensively briefed by the outgoing administration. And they were so impressed by Clarke that they asked him to stay on. But instead of picking up where the Clinton Administration left off, the Bush Administration dropped the ball.

At every level of the administration, counterterrorism was deprioritized. Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill initially resisted eliminating barriers so that terrorist funds could be tracked in off shore banks. Attorney General Ashcroft denied FBI terrorism-funding requests. Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz only had eyes for Iraq, embracing the long discredited notion that al Qaeda was state sponsored. Bush and Cheney were more interested in cutting taxes for the rich and rewarding their corporate donors than heeding the mountain of intelligence that stated al Qaeda was planning something very, very big, or the Aug. 6 presidential brief titled “Bin Laden Determined To Strike In The U.S.,” that suggested airline hijackings.

Could Bush have prevented 9/11 from occurring? Who knows? But the better question is, has Bush done everything he can to prevent the next 9/11? And the answer is sadly, no.

Bush was reluctant to use boots on the ground in Afghanistan. As a result, bin Laden and other top al Qaeda leaders escaped. Now it is too late. Al Qaeda has spread and is no longer dependent on a central leadership. The war in Iraq has diverted funds and resources needed to fight terrorism and the anti-American animosity it has fueled is a terrorist recruiter’s wet dream.

Homeland security also has been shortchanged. A recent article in “The New Republic” reports that the Department of Homeland Security’s only success is in hiding pork. Tom Ridge does not have the power to effect any real change and many key positions in the department remain unfilled. And communication between intelligence organizations is worse now than it was pre-9/11.

The Bush tax cuts and the rising deficit have forced Bush to torpedo many bipartisan requests for desperately needed anti-terrorism funding. The ports and chemical plants remain highly vulnerable, and the FBI still does not have an adequate computer system. Bush has even failed to fund his own programs, such as increasing the number of first responders.

Certainly, the last four administrations all bear some responsibility. But in fairness, the Reagan and Bush 41 administrations were preoccupied by the cold war and unaware of the full extent of the danger represented by terrorism. Clinton identified that threat, made it his top priority and began to implement plans to combat it, even if he did not fully succeed.

But, out of the four, only the current Bush Administration came into office armed with full knowledge of the threat, an experienced counterterrorism staff, and existing and proposed policy to combat future attacks. Yet despite this, the president chose to turn his back on terrorism as he pursued his ideological goals. And for that reason, it is George W. Bush who will bear the greatest liability and blame. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. His intelligence failures may be reported to).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 14, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/041404.pdf?ref=smdp.com)