> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Iraq alternatives make ‘Sophie’s Choice’ seem simple
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/iraq-alternatives-make-sophies-choice-seem-simple/
- Published: 2003-03-13T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:38:38.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ed Silverstein*

While I remain committed to seeing Saddam Hussein ousted from power, my support for the war has become increasingly fragile.

I continue to believe that Saddam represents a threat to the region and the world. I still believe that his people are desperate to be liberated from his brutal regime that, according to one report, is responsible for the deaths of a million and a half people.

And I believe that it is likely that the war would be over quickly and the civilian casualties will be far fewer — unless Saddam unleashes the chemical and biological weapons he claims no longer exist — than if this despot is left unchecked.

My problem with going to war lies in the credibility and motivations behind the Bush-Cheney, or as some people contend, the Cheney-Bush administration.

President Bush has exhibited all the diplomatic subtlety of a steamroller. There seems little question that, had it been George W. Bush, rather than John F. Kennedy, facing the Cuban Missile crisis, the world would have been plunged into a nuclear Armageddon.

Bush’s obstinacy and unwillingness to compromise has created the appearance of a recalcitrant 8-year-old who digs his heels in so deep he has left no room to maneuver. He continues to ignore the burgeoning worldwide peace movement as well as requests from our staunchest allies to find some sort of compromise.

I am even more concerned about the president’s credibility. Bush still clings to his assertion that his tax cut has nothing to do with record deficits or that his proposed new tax cut would not add to that deficit.

If you don’t believe these are bald-face lies just look at Texas. Then-Governor Bush ushered in tax cuts that transformed a $5 billion state surplus into a $12 billion deficit.

The missile defense program is another prime example. Under the guise of national security, the Bush administration has had a suit by a former TRW worker dismissed. The suit alleged that the company was falsifying test results and that the system was fatally flawed.

Rather than proceed cautiously, Bush has rushed to implement the program, yet eliminated all the normal checks and balances and shrouded the program in unheard-of secrecy. In fact Bush’s entire administration is more secretive that any other in memory including Nixon’s. It functions more like a clandestine intelligence agency than as a representative of the American people.

Another case in point is Vice President Dick Cheney’s desperate fight to keep secret the names of those who met to advise on Bush’s energy policy. The policy, which reads like Enron’s corporate mission statement, was obviously created by the executives of energy conglomerates.

Further, as Arianna Huffington pointed out in a recent column, Cheney, when he was secretary of defense in the first Bush Administration, was all for war. Post-Gulf War, as chairmen of oil service giant Halliburton, Cheney cozied up to Saddam and (though he denies it) lobbied hard to end sanctions against Iraq.

Halliburton was rewarded with millions in reconstruction contracts. Now as vice president he is again beating the war drum. Huffington further asserts that Cheney’s staff has already met secretly with U.S. energy concerns, including Halliburton, possibly to discuss divvying up post-Saddam Iraqi oil and reconstruction. It leaves one to wonder if it is President Bush or these energy conglomerates who are making our military policy.

France and Russia’s integrity are equally in question.

It is impossible to believe that the billions Iraq owes to these countries and the very favorable future oil contracts negotiated by Saddam for the express purpose of creating this very rift we see in the United Nations has nothing to do with the positions taken by these countries. It is conceivable they fear post-war disclosures that would reveal their complicity in creating the weapons that threaten the world. Certainly Russia is abetting Iran’s nuclear (weapons?) program, which could result in a crisis potentially far worse than Iraq.

I applaud the peace movement for finally awakening from two decades of apathy and hope it translates into activism concerning the more odious of Bush’s domestic agenda. But at the same time this movement must understand that it cannot prevail without blood on its hands.

Peace has consequences — often deadly. How many Vietnamese and Cambodians were massacred after the U.S. pulled out? And for those of us who railed against apartheid, what about the millions of Africans who were murdered in tribal genocide?

And where are the protests against corrupt black leaders who have stolen white family farms and created food shortages that could result in millions of Africans starving?

There are no easy answers in this conflict. The issues are so complex that it often seems as if “Sophie’s Choice” (a mother forced to make a life and death choice between her two children) would be simpler.

Bearing this in mind, I have a possible solution that could somewhat appease all sides.

Create a resolution, as suggested by the England, that provides realistic but firm timetables for Iraq to destroy or offer concrete accounting of the destruction, of each of its weapons systems, including anthrax, VX, mustard gas, missiles exceeding the 90-mile range and biochemical delivery systems.

France and Russia can determine just what constitutes a reasonable time frame, but they must also agree that if Saddam fails to meet these strict timetables they will support military action.

Finally, in order for Bush to save face, France and Russia, as well as Germany and China, must agree to pony up at least 50 percent of the cost of maintaining the current military build-up in Iraq for as long as the inspections continue. It is only with such compromises that we might have any chance of averting a war, and be able to trust the motivations of all the parties concerned. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in an increasingly scary world. Comments, column ideas and sales on duct tape can be e-mailed to:)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 13, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/031303.pdf?ref=smdp.com)