> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Is it time for an outside audit of Santa Monica College?
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/is-it-time-for-an-outside-audit-of-santa-monica-college/
- Published: 2003-06-14T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T02:20:02.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Eric H. Roth*

Have you heard those ads for the summer session at Santa Monica College yet? They praise Santa Monica College for “holding the line” on student fees, highlight an intensive ESL program and encourage listeners to register.

Those ads, played on several radio stations across Los Angeles, always surprise me. The administration has nothing to do with setting student fees. For worse or for better, the state government sets the fees. The intensive ESL program, designed for foreign students with F-1 visas, has been expanded. Alas, the non-credit ESL program for immigrants and refugees has been cut back by 90 percent this summer. The administration will completely suspend the non-credit ESL program in the fall while spending $7.5 million to build a new arts center in the same Madison site. Finally, SMC is offering fewer summer classes than last year and there isn’t enough room to accommodate current students. What is the point of Santa Monica College’s massive ad campaign?

Perhaps the administration hopes it can distract and deceive the general public about the condition of Santa Monica College and maintain a reputation built on past excellence. Yet the last six months have provided many hard lessons for the students and staff that actually attend and work at the celebrated community college. The administration’s top priority, as many observers have reluctantly concluded, is not keeping as many classes open as possible. Some things — like keeping overpaid administrators and maintaining a vigorous building schedule — are more important than providing an education to community college students.

President Piedad Robertson wants to cut 20-30 percent of classes, abolish several vocational programs, suspend the non-credit ESL program and kick out thousands of students on the pretense of a 5-10 percent state cut in funds. Of course, there are many ways of cutting even that 10 percent that would save jobs, maintain classes, and keep the word “community” in Santa Monica College.

All suggestions and more humane alternatives were rejected without much, if any, real consideration. Why?

The governor’s May revise of the state budget put the actual cuts at no more than 4 percent. President Robertson continued to push for huge cuts in the core business of SMC — educating students.

Meanwhile, the funds continue to roll in for parking lots and buildings at SMC.

What did other community college administrations do? The vast majority of community colleges, which never considered abolishing entire programs, made clear that they would make cuts to reflect no more than 4 percent. A few community colleges in Ventura County announced a cut in salaries across the board to meet any budget shortfall so students could continue taking the same number of classes.

Weeks later, the news from Sacramento looks even better. Due to student activists, faculty pressure and media outrage, the state legislature will be sending a state budget containing far smaller cuts to community colleges — closer to 2 percent.

Alas, President Robertson — pursuing some agenda other than protecting students’ access to classes — continues to push for huge cuts in classes offered and in vast disproportion to the actual cuts in state funding. Why? Wouldn’t reason and decency dictate that cuts, if needed, be kept as far from the classroom as possible? Wouldn’t you cut the number of surplus administrators since SMC has twice as many administrators to full-time faculty as LACC? How is it that other community college districts have avoided making these draconian cuts?

There is something fishy about the zeal of administrators to make these extremely destructive cuts. There are lots of theories floating across the community college campus — personal power, indifference, incompetence, elitism, empire building, fantasies of becoming a four-year university. Yet the bottom line remains that there is no objective reason to abolish entire programs, disregard negotiated contracts, ignore community college procedures, and kick out thousands of minority and disadvantaged students. (Again, why is SMC running all those ads recruiting new students if they will be turning away so many thousands of old students in the fall?) These proposed budget cuts reflect distorted choices and reveal rather perverse priorities for an educational institution.

It’s also worth noting that Santa Monica voters generously taxed themselves $160 million under Proposition U so the college could, in the words of the ballot measure, “increase educational opportunities and raise student achievement” at Santa Monica College.

President Robertson proudly lobbied for the state legislation that authorized capital improvements. The administration wrote and campaigned, with other campus organizations, very hard for the passage of Proposition U to “increase education opportunities and raise student achievement,” which targeted all the funds toward capital improvements. If you are going to write a law, people are going to hold you responsible for the law’s provisions and omissions. Prop. U could have, for instance, included some provision to allow a small percentage to be used, in an emergency, to cover ongoing non-capital costs.

President Robertson, however, defines “educational opportunities” and “student achievement” solely in terms of buildings, and not preserving classes. Meanwhile, the Santa Monica College Foundation continues to raise even more money for buildings, but has failed to host a single fundraiser or send out a single appeal for funds to keep the doors open for community college students. Nor has Santa Monica College attempted to tap its graduates — or even created an alumni list. So, following Robertson’s management, SMC will have far fewer students, but more beautiful buildings next fall. Some consider this enlightened management, others consider it gross mismanagement.

If the administration finds itself needing to cut $9.5 million to make up for a much smaller cut in state funds, then it’s time for an outside audit of the college’s finances.

The strong vote of no confidence, by all campus organizations, shows the great desire for better, more humane and more enlightened educational leadership at Santa Monica College. Perhaps the Board of Trustees can find the courage to review their decisions, reverse course and revitalize the campus. (Eric H. Roth is a former ESL instructor laid off to make room for a $7.5 million new arts center at Madison. Roth now teaches ESL at Cal State University Long Beach.)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 14, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/061403.pdf?ref=smdp.com)