> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Letter: Defending neighborhood opposition to historic district designation
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/letters-20020624/
- Published: 2002-06-24T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T00:22:02.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Eric Charles Parlee Former Santa Monica Planning Commissioner*

The 'ubiquitous Mr. Larmore' that numerous advocates in support of historic districts and landmarks attempt to demonize as the poster boy for anti-preservation must really be a superman. He is alleged to have single handedly organized a neighborhood to inform themselves by observing the practice of the Landmark Commission and decide for themselves whether, upon reflection, historic district or landmark designation is an appropriate or necessary measure to be applied in addition to all other zoning and ordinances governing their property.

He must further be credited with amazing powers of persuasion over historically independent and sophisticated constituents as are homeowners in this community.

The level of orchestrated response from the Renter's Rights/Green Santa Monica Establishment to characterize a legitimate grass roots effort as allegedly organized by one man for politically motivated purposes must be weighed against the politically motivated efforts of spin control, soft peddling and message suppression of the so called preservation advocates and politicians fearful of an issue not their own.

Grass roots efforts are championed by our Establishment if they agree, but not if they don't, and certainly not if they cannot control the process and outcome. This is a natural tendency of an entrenched power structure, as is the tendency to demonize individuals and groups that oppose or question their policies. All this from the generation now established whose youthful mantra was 'question authority'!

The Landmarks Commission has conducted the public process poorly and has therefore become the inadvertent catalyst of the grass roots effort which merely seeks to temper the landmark process by proposing to insert the little caveat of 'owner consent' when it's your home they're talking about.

The commissioners have communicated, however unintentionally, a dismissive, patronizing, if not arrogant attitude towards the average homeowner. Preservation per se is not at the top of most homeowner's desires for either their home or their neighborhood, which is to say that other priorities such as adequate space, reasonably modern amenities, compatibility with established size and setback ordinances, flexibility in design decisions as a matter of personal expression, not to mention economic considerations, probably come first.

The Commission and City Council owe the public the conduct of a balanced and reasonable process reflecting dissimilar and competing points of view rather than one conducted solely by activists for the cause of preservation. The Commission and City Council would do well to remember that a historic district and landmark designation will have more legitimacy and support if the property owners have chosen to take on the obligation to preserve, rather than having it forced on them 'for their own good.' The Third Street Historic District was generated along those lines, therefore why not establish owner consent as the rule, not the exception? Both the Commission and the Council have not done their homework by making convincing and balanced arguments in favor of historic districts, without resorting to putting down those who question the idea. Please pay my mortgage and mow my lawn, Mr. Collectivist, if that's where we're heading.

Preservation has a conservative and protectively rigid stance that must be understood for both its benefits and obligations and should not be entered into lightly or soft peddled as a user friendly exercise with lots of tax benefits. I don't agree with all the concerns against historic districts. It's not likely that your property values will plummet with a historic designation, although you may spend a lot of time, and shell out a lot of cash to hire those with expertise in the preservation field to design and present your case only to come up with nothing but a denial and a suggestion by some of your neighbors that maybe this neighborhood is not for you.

Normally in Santa Monica this kind of treatment is slapped on to Big Bad Developers like Target, Trader Joe's, and the 'ubiquitous' Mr. Jacobs, et al. not your average homeowner. The most recent brouhaha over a two car garage in this our only district, however, gives one much cause for concern, when the experts' opinions could make completely opposite findings, both for and against, and nowhere, either at the Commission or Council level, could the 'tie go to the runner'.

To the partisans in this process, the one expert consultant that you agreed with was a scholar at the pinnacle of the profession, while the other was a paid hack. The whole process also spun out into the personal, as is often the case neighbor to neighbor. As a result, I would imagine quite a few people who witnessed the Commission actions and the Council decision to deny the project must wonder if they would ever want to have plans for their homes subject to such a vitriolic gauntlet that is a Santa Monica public hearing. Ergo spin control.

One looks to government for protection from such a situation, not its facilitation. If buried somewhere in our cultural history 'that government governs best that governs least', where exactly does our current Establishment intend to take us, and is it going to be 'for our own good' no matter what we think?

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 24, 2002.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/062402.pdf?ref=smdp.com)