> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Living wage is part of the world of make believe
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/living-wage-is-part-of-the-world-of-make-believe/
- Published: 2002-10-12T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T00:47:17.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Tom Dilworth*

On a recent Sunday afternoon, a union-funded coalition kicked off its campaign for the Santa Monica living wage, complete with a concert from the musical trio, Peter, Paul & Mary.

This campaign to “lift Santa Monica hotel workers out of poverty” has a harmonious tone, but the “living wage” is far from a magic cure for poverty. Pay mandates like these are blunt tools that target the masses in an effort to help the few in need. In the end, low-skill workers stand to lose — a lot — if the Santa Monica living wage succeeds.

Just like Puff the Magic Dragon, living wage advocates seem to reside in a world of make believe. Living wage debates across the country are typically driven by myths that will not die. The debate in Santa Monica is no different.

By the logic of one myth, a high proportion of workers who would benefit from a living wage are acting as sole support for their families. Research dictates otherwise. A statewide study of Californians on the effects of a $10.25 pay increase illustrates the gap between myth and reality. More than 21 percent of the projected beneficiaries are living with at least one parent. The average family income of the affected worker is $42,530\. Fewer than one in six are in families with an income of less than $12,500\. Most “beneficiaries” live in homes with other earners, and few are officially living in poverty.

So what of the few minimum wage workers who truly are sole supporters? Will they not benefit from a “living wage?” The mythical foundation of the living wage movement strains to answer in the affirmative. Again, sound research suggests otherwise.

By requiring employers to pay a much higher wage for positions once considered entry-level, the government will literally crowd out the least skilled workers. Higher skilled employees will be attracted to the living wage jobs, making it difficult for low-skilled applicants to compete. Interestingly, this is the one point on which advocates, opponents, and impartial observers all agree.

According to a national survey of labor economists in the American Economic Association conducted by the University of New Hampshire Survey Center, nearly eight in 10 labor economists (79 percent) believe that a typical living wage law applied locally would cause employers to hire entry-level employees with greater skills or experience than the applicants they previously hired.

David Reynolds, author of “Living Wage Campaigns: An Activist’s Guide to Building the Movement for Economic Justice,” says the living wage helps businesses “attract and retain the best workers” — without necessarily helping lower-skill workers who currently have the jobs.

University of Massachusetts Professor Robert Pollin, considered the father of the living wage movement has reported: “The other possible effect on employment policies would be through labor substitution — i.e. firms replacing their existing minimum wage employees with workers having better credentials (openings for the covered jobs) would likely attract workers with somewhat better credentials, on average, than those in the existing labor pool.”

So let’s assume there are some low-wage workers who are supporting families and who survive the newfound competition from better-skilled applicants after a living wage passes. They live happily ever after, right? Only in the land of make believe.

In real life, their “raise” will be sapped away by the dreaded “marginal tax rate effect.” That’s a fancy way of saying that as their income rises, beneficiaries will lose the Earned Income Tax Credit and other substantial public assistance benefits. For many, the raise is exposed as — you guessed it — a myth.

So most beneficiaries are not poor. All will see increased competition from higher skilled workers. Some will lose valuable benefits as their mandated increases kick in. This is not a pretty picture. But at least living wage policies reduce poverty, right? After all, proponents often cite a California study as evidence that poverty falls after the living wage takes effect.

But a closer look at the study finds its author stating, “In particular, the estimates indicate that a 50 percent increase in the living wage would reduce the employment rate for workers in the bottom tenth of the skill distribution by 7 percent.” This is a huge hit on those with the least amount of opportunities to get hired.

Santa Monica has a national reputation as a progressive city. It is not known for disregarding the plight of the poor. Perhaps that’s why living wage advocates selected the city to advance their cause. But the living wage movement is built on myth and emotion. Regardless of the feel good rhythms of folk music heroes, the living wage is not a magic cure — all for poverty. For low-skill workers, it brings a dark cloud that does not belong in the magical land Santa Monica residents have worked so hard to create.

Tom Dilworth is the research director for Employment Policies Institute, a nonprofit research organization dedicated to studying public policy issues surrounding entry-level employment.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 12, 2002.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/101202.pdf?ref=smdp.com)