> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Living wage politics are corruption-packed thrill ride
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/living-wage-politics-are-corruption-packed-thrill-ride/
- Published: 2003-07-07T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T02:30:13.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Todd Flora*

In February, a blue ribbon commission of inquiry was convened to investigate questionable tactics used by opponents of Santa Monica’s living wage ordinance.

Particularly under the microscope were a series of detestable tactics used in the “No on JJ” campaign, the 2002 effort against the living wage.

Among the distinguished commission members are a former California State Supreme Court justice, a former board president of California Common Cause, a national board member of the League of Women Voters, a professor of legal ethics, an assistant secretary of state and three of our region’s most revered religious leaders.

Based on evidence gathered from live testimony and documentation, and months of study and deliberation, the commission recently released a devastating report that clearly establishes two things.

First, last year’s campaign against the city’s living wage ordinance was tainted with the most scurrilous and legally questionable campaign tactics. Second, Santa Monica’s big, wealthy hotels were largely responsible for three years of lies and deceit that prevented more than 2,000 low-wage tourism workers from earning a livable wage.

The following are specifics about group that campaigned against the living wage: ■ It spent nearly $2.3 million over three years — an obscene sum for a city Santa Monica’s size; ■ Of the $2.3 million, 83 percent was donated by the hotel industry. The ownership group managing Casa del Mar and Shutters by the Beach contributed 38 percent alone.

Using this largess of funds — which could just have easily gone to comply with the living wage ordinance benefiting housekeepers, valets, and dishwashers — the hotels hired several illusory figures to conduct what they confessed to city leaders would be a “scorched earth” campaign against the living wage movement.

This colorful cabal of mysterious figures plays out like bad dinner theater. The primary consultants hired by those opposed to the living wage were the Dolphin Group, a firm with a reputation for deceptive tactics and close ties to the tobacco industry.

Also included in this scheme was William “Lord” Butcher, a right-wing political consultant who drafted the language for three controversial campaign mailings used in the last week of the Proposition JJ campaign.

One mailer, sponsored by an illegitimate “Pro-Choice Voters Committee,” asked pro-choice voters to oppose the living wage. A second was sent by an equally mysterious “Quality Schools Coalition,” which threw in a plea to vote “No on JJ” with calls to support state and local school measures.

Third, opponents sent a “Democratic Voters Ballot Guide for Santa Monica,” which directed voters to support all of the state’s Democratic Party nominees, but to oppose the living wage ordinance. Lt. Governor Cruz Bustamante was so bothered by his name and image being associated with opposition to the living wage, he personally testified before the commission of inquiry, calling for electoral reform.

How can this practice possibly be allowed to take place under the law in this state, especially given that the Democratic Party supported the living wage ordinance and legitimate pro-choice and education groups had no position one way or another?

It’s no surprise that the “treasurer” named for the “organizations” supporting the three campaign mailers — James Lacy — is a recognized advocate against tighter restrictions on slate mailer requirements. Lacy has even sued the state to prevent implementation of reform measures pertaining to political slate mailings.

But Lacy and his friends are hardly practicing freedom of speech. Their methods are a distortion of truth hiding behind loopholes in the law.

Rounding out the cast is Colleen McAndrews, the treasurer for the overall “No on JJ” campaign. By amazing coincidence, McAndrews works for the political consulting firm managed by William Lord Butcher.

But this didn’t stop the official No on JJ campaign from — with a straight face no less — claiming no knowledge of Butcher’s campaign mailers. I mean, who ARE these people?

With this damage done, we as a community need to keep our eyes on the ball. More than 2,000 low-wage tourism workers still need wages that will help free many of them from (your) taxpayer-funded public assistance.

And at the end of the day, all of the sleazy work by all the dirty consultants in the world would not have been possible without Santa Monica’s biggest, wealthi-est hotels bankrolling the effort.

The commission of inquiry included several recommendations for reform in their report, which can be found at http://www.democracydistorted.com/arti cles.html.

Whatever our respective views on the living wage, historic landmarks, parcel tax measures, or City Council candidates, we must unite against this kind of “democracy abuse.” Without a vibrant ethical code at the helm, which local proposition that you care about might be next? (Todd Flora is a contributing columnist to the Daily Press. A former state director of the California Clean Money Campaign, he is a communications and issues manager and six-year resident of Santa Monica.)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 7, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/070703.pdf?ref=smdp.com)