> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# ‘Mind’ over matter: Buck stops with Bush
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/mind-over-matter-buck-stops-with-bush/
- Published: 2004-07-21T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:23:11.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

The Senate intelligence committee released a 500-page report last week that detailed how the CIA and other intelligence agencies failed to recruit spies in Iraq, relied on questionable sources, ignored all contrary evidence and made hasty assumptions about Iraqi WMDs. Republicans and Democrats were unanimous in terming it one of the worst intelligence failures in our history.

The bipartisan love fest, however, came to shrieking halt when it came to the question of whether President Bush and members of his administration pressured these agencies to provide analysis that supported their desire to go to war.

Republican Sen. Pat Roberts, the chairman of the committee, claims that there was no White House pressure, which was the official position of the committee. Sen. Jay Rockefeller, the ranking Democrat, strongly disagrees. Rockefeller asserts that the Republican-controlled committee created a definition for what constituted pressure that was so narrow that only requests to change information directly from the White House would have qualified.

Of course there’s ample evidence that the Bush administration exaggerated the flawed intelligence to make it sound far more ominous. And it is also likely that the president exerted intense pressure on the CIA to find or create a connection between Iraq and al Qaeda. But, thanks to Pat Roberts, an ardent Bush supporter, committee findings on these issues will be delayed until after the election.

But as to the question of whether the White House exerted undo influence on intelligence pertaining to Iraq’s WMD program and by extension, plunged the United States into an increasingly untenable war, one need only explore Bush’s past record.

Franklin Foer, in his article for The New Republic, “Closing of the Presidential Mind,” makes a convincing case that the entire administration is distrustful and contemptuous of experts. They have made a practice of bullying or, that failing, eschewing the advice of any who refuse to kowtow to their ideological dogma.

One example forwarded by Foer were the order to the EPA not to undertake normal scientific and economic studies on the effects of mercury emissions when the administration wanted to loosen restrictions and the editing of EPA reports on the environment and global warming that was so extensive that the EPA refused to release them. And when the FDA’s scientific panel explored 40 studies and 15,000 pages of data arriving at an overwhelming recommendation that morning after pills should be sold over the counter, they were perfunctorily overruled. And the findings of six scientists hired by the National Marine Fisheries, who decried the health of West Coast fisheries were just eliminated from the final report.

Another blatant example of manipulation are the Bushes’ penchant of sending analysts back to the drawing board when they present a report that doesn’t reflect the administration’s preconceived (and I use this word loosely) thinking. Such was the case when terrorism expert, Richard Clark, reported to President Bush that there was no connection between Iraq and al Qaeda or 9/11\. And Bob Woodward’s book, “Plan Of Attack,” details how Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld rejected war plan after war plan until General Tommy Franks finally presented a plan that called for far fewer troops — a pet theory of Rumsfeld’s and one of the main contributing factors leading to our current quagmire in Iraq.

And when George Tenant’s CIA wasn’t providing analysis to the administration’s liking, including warnings about putting too much faith in the Neocon’s then golden haired boy, Ahmed Chalabi, Rumsfeld created a more responsive shadow intelligence agency in the Pentagon to pressure Tenant to fall into line. And according to the LA Times, at the request of the administration, former CIA Director R. James Woolsey — a consultant with great influence with the agency — set up the Committee for the Liberation of Iraq, an organization set up to advocate war.

An even more egregious example of Bush administration coercion and intimidation, involves the threat or actual firing anyone who does anything to compromise the administrations agenda. This was the case when Medicare Chief, Thomas Scully, threatened to fire a cost analyst if he told Congress the true price of the Medicare prescription plan. Bush also removed members of his bio-ethics panel because they did not adhere to his religious based views and fired members of the U.S. Forest Service because they disagreed with his policies that they felt threatened the health of national forests. The head of the U.S. Parks Department was fired when she warned that staff cuts had left the park open to criminal activity.

Bush also forced the resignation of one of his few honest brokers, Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill, for not embracing his destructive economic policies. When O’Neill fought back with a book, the Bush mafia launched one of their signature media blitz/character assassinations. Richard Clarke met the same fate. And when former Ambassador Wilson discredited Bush’s State of The Union claim that Iraq was trying to obtain yellowcake uranium from Nigeria, a top Bush official outted Wilson’s wife, an undercover CIA operative, thus endangering her life and those of any spies she had recruited.

And, while it seems that none of these incidents constitute pressure under the partisan guidelines of the Senate Intelligence Committee, the message from the Bush administration couldn’t be clearer: Disagree with the president and you’ll derail your career, be discredited, fired and your family might be killed.

That is not to say that the CIA and other intelligence agencies don’t deserve the lion’s share of blame for this failure. They do. But anyone who claims that the White House did not pressure intelligence agencies to hype Iraq’s WMD programs, was likely pressured by the administration to say so. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Requests for copies of this column or comments may be sent to:)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 21, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/072104.pdf?ref=smdp.com)