> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# New Medicare bill throws seniors to the wolves
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/new-medicare-bill-throws-seniors-to-the-wolves/
- Published: 2003-12-03T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:19:50.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ed Silverstein*

A few years ago my niece, then 18 months, suffered a severe leg break when her sister tripped taking her out of the crib. Her frantic parents rushed her to the emergency room where she was fitted with a partial body cast.

The doctors warned that the break might leave the toddler with a permanent limp. For her parents, the next few weeks were filled with severe anxiety, as well as the challenges of occupying an active child nearly immobilized by the cast. The cast finally was removed, and to everyone’s relief, my niece was fine.

Less pleasant was the notification by their HMO, Empire Blue Cross, that $2000 of their emergency room claim was being denied.

The basis for the denial was a single sentence buried in a 76-page rulebook. It states that the HMO must be notified of an emergency-room visit within 24 hours — or as soon as reasonably possible — otherwise half the claim will be denied.

Unfortunately for my wife’s sister and her husband, they were too busy worrying about whether their child would ever walk properly again to wade through a massive tome that, as far as I can see, has no other purpose but to create criteria in which to deny otherwise legitimate claims.

Now the Bush Administration and the Republican party leadership, with the inexplicable collusion of the AARP, have passed their version of the Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Bill. It is weighted with enough industry pork to make even a pig farmer jealous. Bush, under threat of veto, insisted on a shameless prohibition against Medicare’s negotiating for price reductions on prescription drugs.

What is more of a concern is that this bill is the first step in a neo-conservative plan to dismantle and privatize Medicare, one of the country’s most successful programs. True, the initial assault will rely on coaxing seniors into private HMOs by enticing them with additional benefits. The extra costs are not coming out of the pockets of the health-insurance industry, but rather will be footed by taxpayers by way of tax cuts and giveaways.

But what about seniors who elect to join HMOs? They will likely find themselves navigating the same confusing maze of treacherous rules that tripped up my sister and brother-in-law. And this will be far more overwhelming for those seniors who suffer from memory lapses, impaired vision, physical disabilities or age-related dementia.

My 95-year-old grandmother is amazing, but she is not capable of memorizing a 76-page book. And every time she has to go to a doctor she must hire an aid to accompany her, so forcing her to first see a primary care doctor to approve a visit to a specialist creates an undo burden. At her age, even such a brief delay could result in a minor condition’s deteriorating into one that is life threatening.

And don’t expect the HMOs to show seniors any special consideration. Shortly after Empire Blue Cross denied my niece’s emergency room claim, my brother-in-law was killed in the World Trade Center attack. Sympathy and support poured in from everywhere with one notable exception.

Despite my repeated appeals to personnel at every level in the organization, including their CEO Dr. Michael Stocker, Empire Blue Cross refused to budge. They adamantly stood behind a heartless and highly questionable policy that took away money from a tragically widowed woman left alone with three young kids.

Add to this callousness the strong opposition by Bush and top Republicans to any meaningful Patients Bill of Rights, and seniors who opt into HMOs might very well find themselves in a nightmare.

We must stop this scheme now. The AARP must work with moderate Republicans and thinking Democrats to revoke special-interest provisions that are intended to seduce seniors out of Medicare and will raise the cost of health care. And in light of record deficits, it’s unconscionable to allow a prohibition against using Medicare’s vast buying power to reduce the price of prescription drugs.

We must ensure that those in their golden years are guaranteed the best medical care possible. They have earned it and have paid for it. And, after all, aging creates enough natural hardships for seniors without our government throwing them to the wolves. (Ed Silverstein is a free-lance writer aging in Santa Monica. Comments can be e-mailed to).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 3, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/120303.pdf?ref=smdp.com)