> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# No miracle on 34th Street: A modern day Christmas story
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/no-miracle-on-34th-street-a-modern-day-christmas-story/
- Published: 2004-12-22T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:31:33.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

In an attempt to get into the holiday spirit, I viewed the perennial Christmas classic, “Miracle On 34th Street.” All I can tell you is that I was appalled.

Sure, the first 50 times I saw the film I was enthralled by its magic, innocent charm and heart lifting sentiment. But that’s all changed. “Miracle” is a dangerous fiction in today’s’ politically correct, sexually crazed, prudish, terrorist fearing, zero tolerant, publicity seeking, parentally paranoid, litigious society.

The film runs into trouble almost immediately. What is Susan Walker, a perky 7-year old, doing hanging out without parental supervision or knowledge in the apartment of Fred Gailey, a 40 year-old bachelor?

If this happened today, Doris Walker, Susan’s mom, would be on the sex offender Web site faster than you could say Michael Jackson. And if Freddy boy weren’t on the list then, he would be now.

Of course this doesn’t let Doris off the hook. Odds are some ambitious prosecutor, looking to make a name for himself, would have Walker up on child endangerment charges. And there is no doubt child services, fearing for the child’s safety, would feel compelled to remove Susan from the home and place her with a foster family where it is almost certain she would molested and abused.

And then there’s the whole Kris Kringle thing. I mean, does anybody buy the fact that this previously unemployed nut case is living, for free, in a senior home, with its own staff doctor in wealthy Greatneck, Long Island? Face it, in real life, thanks to Ronnie Reagan, Kris would be living on the streets of Santa Monica and having a good cry with former City Councilman Michael Feinstein.

Then there’s the whole employment fiasco. The guy is hired without proper documentation, such as proof of citizenship, which breaks, I don’t know, maybe 3,000 Patriot Act provisions. And then there is the conspicuous absence of New York Attorney General Elliot Spitzer shoring up his gubernatorial bid with a televised news conference calling for sanctions against Macy’s.

And if this Kringle guy’s claim that he is from the North Pole is true, then the guy’s an illegal alien, without a green card, and should be kicked out of the country. This is good news for Democrats as they will be able to use this information against Republicans when they try to use Santa Claus as their next wedge issue.

And if Mrs. Walker doesn’t have enough legal problems, she lets Kringle hang with her daughter, in the girl’s bedroom, even after she is advised that the guy is a whacko.

And let’s look at Macy’s itself. I figure it’s good for half a dozen lawsuits. First we have a racial discrimination suit because there was not even a single black or Hispanic employee. In fact, the only black person I saw in the movie was the maid, who would surely have been fired after the nanny cam caught her allowing Susan to go off with Fred.

We also can assume there would be an assortment of wrongful termination and age discrimination suits by the drunk Santa and Kris Kringle, not to mention defamation of character for accusing Kringle of being insane. Sawyer, the pseudo shrink, would no doubt file a disability claim after being knocked on the head by Kringle, along with his restraining order, and assault and battery charge. And let’s not forget the class action for allowing a mentally unstable Santa around children.

And then we come to the trial. Let’s forget that, once the trial hit the front page, Kringle didn’t dump Gailey for the likes of Johnny Cochran. Or that Mr. Macy, testifying that his employee, Kringle, is the one and only Santa Claus, has about as much veracity as tobacco company execs swearing before Congress that smoking isn’t dangerous. And let’s even assume that legal hack Gailey prevails in his effort to prove Kringle is the one and only Santa Claus.

Within hours, the ACLU would launch a suit against the U.S. Post Office for violating the separation of Church and State. Kringle would seek a cease and desist order for use of his likeness without permission, then would seek damages in the tens of billions. Madonna, with a group of Santa believers, would make a pilgrimage to the North Pole. Brittany Spears would marry Kringle and Christina Aguilera, trying to out-slut Brittany, would sleep with the reindeers.

As for the happy ending — for-getaboutit. There ain’t no way that a bottom-feeding lawyer and a low-level department store executive can afford, what is now, a $1.5 million house in Manhasset. Of course they’ll still get married, but Doris would quickly become frustrated by Fred’s unrealistic desire to defend whack jobs like Kringle and start demanding that he take on more lucrative cases, like defending Mr. Macy for inflating profits. I give them nine months.

And finally Susan, having lost whatever little faith she had in humanity thanks to Kringle’s broken promises, runs away with her ex-stepfather at 16, develops a $400 a day drug habit, finds religion, kicks drugs and her stepfather, writes a tell-all book about the Santa Claus scam that spends 145 weeks on the best seller list, buys that house in Manhasset and lives happily ever after.

Next Christmas: It’s Not A Wonderful life. Happy Holidays. (Comments or requests for copies of this column can be e-mailed to).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 22, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/122204.pdf?ref=smdp.com)