> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Nomination process
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/nomination-process/
- Published: 2006-01-12T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T22:59:33.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*just a shot in dark*

*By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOHN W. WHITEHEAD*

The fact that Harriet Miers was forced to withdraw her name for a Supreme Court seat raises real concerns about the nomination process. Before the American people could even hear what she had to say in her testimony before Congress, she was completely demonized by right-wing interest groups. And of course the media, with a giddy zeal, attempted to find out every personal tidbit about this lady in exposing any weaknesses. Now, the exacting and wearisome nomination process begins again, this time with Samuel Alito. Because of Alito’s conservative record, some in Congress are threatening a fight over the Alito nomination.

However, with all the scrutiny and attention paid to possible Supreme Court justices in today’s media, some of the greatest judges to ever sit on the Supreme Court would never have made it to the bench.

For example, Justice Hugo Black was a staunch advocate for the Bill of Rights. During the anti-communist McCarthy era of the 1950s, Black consistently voted to uphold the First Amendment rights of those brought under the heavy hand of the government. He also wrote the unanimous opinion in the 1963 case of Gideon vs. Wainwright, which guaranteed the right of all defendants to be represented by a lawyer in state criminal trials. Black was famous for pulling a pocket Constitution from inside his coat jacket and liberally quoting from it.

However, in the 1920s, Black was a member of the Ku Klux Klan. In 1921, he defended Klansmen accused of murdering a priest. Although he later disavowed his membership in the Klan, in today’s over-scrutinized attention paid to the background of potential nominees, Black would have been slaughtered like a sacrificial lamb on the altar of politics.

When Earl Warren was a district attorney, he was noted for being “tough on crime.” And later as the Republican governor of California, Warren exuded a conservative bias. But President Eisenhower was surprised that Warren turned out to be more liberal than he appeared.

Indeed, it was Chief Justice Warren who wrote the opinion in the landmark decision of Brown vs. Board of Education in 1954, which did away with the segregation of public schools.

He also wrote the opinion in Miranda vs. Arizona, which required that the rights of people arrested be explained to them, including the right to an attorney — often called the “miranda warnings.” Warren later headed up the Warren Commission to investigate the circumstances of John Kennedy’s assassination. But when he was governor of California, he supported the internment of Japanese-Americans in concentration camps during World War II. Because of this, it is quite unlikely that he would ever have made it to the Supreme Court.

One of the complaints lodged against Miers was that she was never a judge. However, Robert Jackson, considered one of the great Supreme Court justices of all time, did not even attend college and was never a judge.

Finally, William Rehnquist, whose vacancy was recently filled by John Roberts, had a lurid past, some have argued. While a student at Stanford University, Jewish classmates were allegedly outraged by Rehnquist goose-stepping and “Heil Hitlering” with friends in front of a dormitory for Jewish students. He was an attorney in private practice in Phoenix, Ariz., in the mid-’50s to the late ’60s. In 1964, Rehnquist voiced opposition to the Phoenix City Council’s proposed Public Accommodation Ordinance, which permitted blacks to enter stores and restaurants. In fact, according to George Brooks, president of the Phoenix NAACP chapter from 1963 to 1972, one evening when he and other civil-rights activists were picketing in front of the Arizona State House, Rehnquist emerged from the building.

“He remonstrated against us,” Brooks said. Others have testified to the altercation, which Rehnquist says didn’t happen — even claiming under oath, to Brooks’ amusement, that he did not know anyone by the name of George Brooks. Several witnesses even stated under oath that Rehnquist harassed minority voters in the early 1960s — primarily black and Hispanic. Rehnquist also owned property containing restrictive covenants barring its sale to nonwhites and Jews. These facts alone today would destroy any chance of Rehnquist ever sitting on the Supreme Court. But he went on to serve on the court 33 years and was one of the longest-sitting chief justices ever — 19 years. And while his opinions were not memorable, they did nothing to dismantle the staid Supreme Court.

Clearly, the current nomination process forces presidents to pick nominees with no past. These are people who hide what they believe and hold a politically correct view of almost everything. They are stealth candidates like Roberts who, in his testimony before Congress, revealed virtually nothing. In the process, the sort of diversity needed on the Supreme Court will never exist again under the current procedure.

On one side, the interest groups scream and spend millions of dollars to either bolster or destroy the candidate. Consider the case of Judge Robert Bork, nominated to the court by Ronald Reagan. Interest groups spent an unprecedented $20 million in campaigns to either demonize or praise him. Bork was so scrutinized that he was criticized for his movie rentals — such as “A Day at the Races,” “Ruthless People” and, amazingly, Alfred Hitchcock’s “The Man Who Knew Too Much.”

On the other side is the celebrity-driven media fed by leaks from government agents that attempt to expose every weakness of the individual. And who gets left out of the process? As usual, the American people. (Contact constitutional attorney John W. Whitehead at)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 12, 2006.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/011206.pdf?ref=smdp.com)