> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Organizers manipulated students
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/organizers-manipulated-students/
- Published: 2002-04-20T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T00:14:46.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Richard Firth Santa Monica*

Editor: In responding to my letter, Oscar de la Torre sets forth some interesting arguments in favor of the rally and march he helped organize at Samohi. He also underlines one of my chief points... that I did not attend his event. I am not a student, teacher or administrator at Samohi. I, therefore, would have had no business being on campus during the day when those who took part in the rally and march were “invited” to participate. If I had just wandered onto school grounds midday, I would have been questioned at the gate as to my reasons for being there and campus security would have denied me access. Sorry, that argument doesn't work.

During the peaceful march, which appears to have followed, the organizers and students were monitored by the Santa Monica Police at every turn. Interestingly enough, the photo accompanying the story shows professionally printed picket signs which may account for the concern by police that outside interests might be present and cause trouble.

Based on Mr. de la Torre’s letter and coverage of the event in the press (remember I wasn't there), here is what I have to conclude took place: Mr. de la Torre and Ms. Delores Huerta (and other community leaders) were invited to participate in the unveiling of a recently completed mural honoring the late Cesar Chavez. The event was planned to “celebrate the vision and values of Cesar E. Chavez” and to “provide meaningful opportunities for students to engage in activities that educate the heart and mind.” These community leaders organized two campus forums to this end in which Ms. Huerta discussed “the importance of a workers union (and) spoke to the students about the values of non-violence, compassion, unity, racial equality and social justice.” I think that is exactly what I advocated in my previous letter.

The fact that the students were then invited to “attend an after school march in support of the workers at the Doubletree Hotel” under the guise of living “the vision of Cesar E. Chavez and to practice their First Amendment right in a peaceful demonstration” is manipulative, at best.

A campus forum, which I completely support, was turned into a way for Mr. de la Torre, Ms. Huerta and the other interested community leaders to stage a rally and march on the Doubletree from a Samohi base of operations. If Mr. de la Torre and the other organizers had gone to the Samohi administration or the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District and said that they wanted to stage an after school, pro-labor rally and march in support of the Doubletree workers, beginning and ending on the school campus, what do you think that the answer would have been?

The educational exercise Mr. de la Torre refers to was not in support of A cause, it was in support of HIS cause (and that of Ms. Huerga).

The march was obviously pre-planned and that was the only cause offered for student participation from what I can tell from Mr. de la Torre’s letter. It is not so much that the students were coerced into participation, it is that it seems that they were subtly manipulated.

I completely support the philosophy of non-violence and I am happy to hear that the forums and rally organized at least in part by Mr. de la Torre carried forth and advocated this means of protest. Unfortunately, not everyone agrees with us. There are those who disagree with the labor cause... sometimes violently. I was not so much worried about violence from the students, the faculty or the community organizers as much as I was worried about outside forces who might react negatively and violently based on the rally and march.

Finally, I find it very interesting that Mr. de la Torre’s first question was to ask who I was and not whether what I was saying made any sense. It would appear that he would like to assume that I am in some way connected with the Doubletree and therefore a voice for corporate management instead of a voice for reason. I’m sorry to disappoint him but I’m just a Samohi parent and Santa Monica community resident who opposes manipulation of the Samohi campus community for any cause.

I am a Samohi graduate. I have been active in supporting Samohi as a parent by serving on various committees and attending campus activities. Otherwise, I come to the campus in the morning to drop off and in afternoon to pick up my child. Between those times, I assume that the administrators and faculty are doing their job to educate the students and that the students are in class learning, which is their job.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 20, 2002.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/042002.pdf?ref=smdp.com)