> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Our leaders should know
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/our-leaders-should-know/
- Published: 2004-04-22T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:55:02.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Lara M. Brown, Ph.D.*

Today, I’m doing something I don’t usually do. I’m writing on foreign affairs. I don’t usually do this because while my doctorate is in political science, my field is not international relations. I admit freely that my knowledge of the rest of the world is limited, at best.

But I’m doing this today because I am heartsick. The events of the past few weeks in Iraq have been too horrific. I feel compelled to comment.

Two things you should know about where I’ve stood all along: I am not against the war in Iraq. I am only against the way President Bush chose to fight it.

I believe that Iraq is a problem because it has three religious populations within its borders that don’t like each other. I believe that we need to somehow make right our past of abandoning Iraqi Kurds without losing our diplomatic ties with Turkey. I believe that Saudi Arabia is pressuring us to move our troops, and that we need to rethink our strategic placements in the region. I believe that Saddam Hussein had been flouting the United Nations’ weapons inspectors for years because he was likely up to no good. For these reasons and others — oil and tyranny, being two of them — I believe that getting rid of Saddam Hussein was on balance a good thing, rather than a bad thing.

While I had reservations about the timing of the war and the imminence of the threat, I felt that eventually we would need to go to Iraq, so I was less concerned than many others about the “preemp-tion” debate. Our history suggests preemption has long been our preferred method of prevention (see Gore Vidal for further explanation). Likewise, while I wished we had done more to court allies from surrounding nations (i.e., agreeing to pay Turkey to use their bases) and Europe, I also understood that foreign relations often is fraught with intractable issues relating to self-interest (i.e., France and Germany, each not wanting to give up their oil servicing contracts in Iraq).

Where I depart significantly from the neo-conservatives in the White House and from the Democrats who are hawks, is that I believe that “shock and awe” is a seriously flawed strategy. You can’t win over a populace through humiliation. Raw aggression is almost always met with capitulation, followed by revenge.

It is the stuff Hollywood movies are made of. The difference is that when you watch a movie, you root for the people who were first made the victims.

In this war, Hussein didn’t fight and the Iraqis became the victims. We ran through the country faster than anyone thought we would. We overwhelmed them with our military might. As a result, many Iraqis (and Muslim extremists who watched on cable and then went to Iraq after Bush declared victory on board the USS Lincoln) came to see us as conquerors, and not liberators.

I watched our troops on CNN — before they reached Baghdad, before the statue of Saddam fell — surround one pink truck with an automatic rifle welded to the top. Our soldiers closed in on the truck using maybe seven armored tanks. My thoughts were, as I watched the visuals coming back from an embedded reporter, “drug dealers are better armed than the Iraqi army.”

It goes without saying that I was relieved that our troops were met with so little resistance on their mission to Baghdad, but I was worried about the impression we were leaving with the Iraqi people on the way.

I prayed for our soldiers because I knew that they would be in trouble, eventually.

Here’s the thing: War is dangerous. I study wars that have had unfathomable casualty numbers, like the Civil War — but I was particularly concerned about this war because the thinking that went into “shock and awe” seemed so profoundly uninformed about human nature.

There seemed to me to be such a serious underestimation of how people react — forget Iraqis, forget terrorists, forget all the differences that make politics so complex.

What terrified me most about the Bush White House, was not that we were going to war, but that they did not seem to have an understanding of human nature.

And this is what is at the crux of politics. This is the most basic thing that leaders are supposed to know: What is the nature of man and how do you create a society to best fit that nature? If you cannot answer these questions, you should not be engaged in nation-building. Period.

There were other ways to topple Hussein’s government, but President Bush chose to humiliate, and so while we may have won the battle of Iraq, we are now losing the war. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is an education policy consultant and a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for Social Science Research. She).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 22, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/042204.pdf?ref=smdp.com)