> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Outsourcing: Adding to our fears of flying
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/outsourcing-adding-to-our-fears-of-flying/
- Published: 2005-02-14T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:13:01.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By CAROLE ORLIN*

I recall hearing repeated references during the 2004 presidential campaign about “outsourcing.” The Kerry-Edwards campaign pressed the evils of the out-sourcing of U.S. jobs to foreign countries. On the surface, it seemed to me to be a “hot” economic button.

As an American, I was outraged at the thought of even one American losing a job because of offshore outsourcing (“offshoring”). My only personal experience with outsourcing in the last year came from calling an 800 number to discuss a computer question with a major U.S. company. After being frustrated over the course of several days and many calls to the company, I tried to determine which office was handling (or mishandling) my calls. Was it New York or Chicago or San Jose? Well, it was none of the above. I was speaking to someone trying to help from India.

A few days later, I remember watching a segment on one of the network news/magazine shows — I believe it was “60 Minutes” — that focused on companies in the United States utilizing educated workers in developing countries, such as India or China, who would work for dramatically lower wages than in developed countries. The assumption, of course, was that the lower wages would not result in inferior services or products. To the contrary, the claim was made that the jobs were so competitive in these developing countries that the chosen few who were selected were much more qualified than their higher-paid counterparts in this country. The benefits to the businesses in having reduced (overseas) labor costs would yield higher profits for the companies and better prices for the consumers.

The obvious negatives for our country relate to unemployment, and to what extent this type of offshore outsourcing has been a contributing factor to the highly debated “jobless recovery.” Was out-sourcing to blame for the higher-than-expected unemployment numbers during the 2001 through 2003 period? Several former chairmen of the Council of Economic Advisers under Presidents Clinton and Carter rejected this hypothesis. Their analysis revealed that the number of service-sector jobs lost during that period was a very small percentage of the working population (approximately 215,000 out of 150 million). Furthermore, when looking at balancing the amount of money that remained in the foreign country, such as India, against the amount of money coming back into the United States by virtue of cost savings, new exports, repatriated profits and productivity gains, the U.S. economy actually gained between $1.12 and $1.14 for each dollar that was invested in outsourcing.

This economic debate will certainly continue. My main concern about out-sourcing comes from a story that appeared several weeks ago in The Wall Street Journal (Jan. 21, 2005), and repeated in numerous print and broadcast media reports since then. The story reports on the increasingly popular practice of a number of airlines of cutting costs by outsourcing major repairs and maintenance for their aircrafts to contractors in other countries with lower-paid mechanics. Among the airlines that are outsourcing their airplane maintenance are: JetBlue, which sends its A320 Airbus to El Salvador; America West, which also sends its jets to El Salvador; Southwest, which has always outsourced its major maintenance; US Airways, whose mechanics last month agreed to the outsourcing of 2,000 mechanic jobs; Northwest Airlines, which sends its wide-body jets to Singapore and Hong Kong for repairs; (bankrupt) United Airlines, which recently won union approval to begin outsourcing its heavy maintenance. American Airlines keeps its heavy maintenance in-house and out-sources only 20 percent of its maintenance.

Until recently, the major airlines employed their own highly skilled mechanics who needed an Aviation Administration license to work on the aircrafts. This license was acquired after up to two years of study prior to taking the licensing test. Only supervisors at the out-sourced repair stations are required to have a license; the mechanics do not have to be licensed. Is outsourcing our airplanes to unlicensed contractors endangering our safety? The airlines say that their overseas contractors are more tightly supervised than their own contractors. However, investigators into the 2003 Charlotte, N.C., commuter flight crash that killed 21 people cited deficient maintenance by an outside vendor and lack of regulatory oversight as partly to blame. In 1999, the ValuJet flight 592 crash was attributed to oxygen canisters improperly stowed in the aircraft’s hold by employees working for an outside contractor.

In addition to these safety concerns, the issue we all confront after 9/11 is the possibility of terrorist infiltration into these airplane maintenance shops. A troubling incident occurred in 2001 with SASCO (ST Aerospace), the company that works on Northwest DC-10 aircrafts in Singapore. When authorities in Singapore arrested 13 people suspected of having ties to Al Qaeda, one of them was a SASCO aircraft technician, who is alleged to have taken more than 50 pictures of military planes and facilities at an adjacent U.S. airbase. Northwest issued a statement saying that the suspect did not work on Northwest planes, and that they were working with SASCO to implement enhanced security measures. Are foreign maintenance personnel subjected to the same standards of background security checks, criminal background checks and identification for access to facilities that apply in the United States?

Total FAA inspections were up in 2003, and were scheduled to be even higher in 2004, but it is not clear how many of these inspections are for out-sourced repair shops. Despite the FAA’s assurances that problems are being corrected, I have serious questions with their ability to address the multitude of problems that result from outsourcing of something with such potential catastrophic consequences as airplane maintenance. I hope we do not have to experience another major disaster before we really take a close look at what we are willing to risk in order to save money. (Carole)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 14, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/021405.pdf?ref=smdp.com)