> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Pardon the pundits, it was politics as unusual
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/pardon-the-pundits-it-was-politics-as-unusual/
- Published: 2004-07-14T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:21:35.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By BETH SOLOMON*

WASHINGTON — Something strange happened Sunday morning. It looked at first like a regular summer day. The sun rose. Birds chirped. As usual, Washington pundits and politicians were locked and loaded in front of TV cameras, ready to debate.

On NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Sens. Pat Roberts (R-Kan.) and Jay Rockefeller (D- W.Va.) presented a congressional report saying the Iraq war was based on false premises. The CIA laid an egg, they said, putting its trust in a fellow named Curveball who told a great story about Saddam’s massive Weapons of Mass Destruction. It turned out to be false. Hooey. Made up. Curveball said Saddam was gearing up to drop the big one. On us. Seriously. A regime that couldn’t keep the electricity running in Baghdad — even before we bombed the place. As crazy as it sounds, some guys in Washington believed Curveball. Believed him 110 percent. They looked into his eyes. But they didn’t notice that he was also the son of the self-styled successor to Saddam, the U.S. government’s favorite stool-pigeon — I mean toady — I mean exile — Ahmed Chalabi. Or maybe they did notice. Or maybe we were the pigeon. Anyway. This was the normal part of the morning.

The Senators disagreed on whether to release the second half of their report before the election. Democrat Rockefeller said they should.

SEN. ROBERTS: No, no, no. We’ve been working on this since February, Jay.

SEN. ROCKEFELLER: A little bit of work on Douglas Feith. But the work we...

SEN. ROBERTS: We... SEN. ROCKEFELLER: Let me finish. The work...

SEN. ROBERTS: I know, but we tried to have him up, and you won’t have him up.

SEN. ROCKEFELLER: No, I’ve asked you to have him up again. He’s been up once. Let’s not get into that.

They argued. It was fairly polite for Washington. That part was unusual.

But then the really strange stuff started happening.

William F. Buckley, Jr., sometimes called the founder of the conservative movement, came on the show to mark the end of a 49-year career as editor of the National Review. He was joined by long-time liberal Baltimore Sun commentator Jack Germond, and the dean of Washington pundits, the Washington Post’s David Broder. The combined age of this group nearly exceeds the GNP of a small country, but let’s not get into that. The youngster on the panel, the brainy Ron Brownstein of the Los Angeles Times, tipped his hat to Ronald Reagan and forgave them for their “youth and inexperience.”

That was funny. It was nice. Nice? Things were about to get even more weird.

Brownstein’s fellow youngster 50-something Tim Russert asked Buckley about the presidential race. “Here’s the latest Time magazine poll,” Russert offered, “John Kerry 47 percent, George Bush 45 percent, Ralph Nader, 3.5\. And then this question: ‘Who do you trust more to lead the country?’ George Bush 46 percent, John Kerry 46 percent. How do you see the race playing out over the next couple of months?”

Said Buckley, “Well, 47 percent are wrong. In other words, your job is to get them up to speed.”

It was a joke. Buckley grinned. The panel smiled. There was no yelling, no name-calling, no venom.

It was weird. Germond tried to get things back on track. He scoffed that nobody cares about the significance of Democratic Vice Presidential candidate John Edwards for the Democratic ticket, or how prepared he is to be president. “I mean, this is typical of the kind of nonsense we talk about in presidential campaigns these days,” Germond frowned. “We’re not talking about things that have any meaning for voters. That’s why they don’t vote. Because we don’t talk about the things they care about. They don’t care about this stuff. Forget it.”

Germond has written a book called “Fat Man Fed Up: How American Politics Went Bad.” Surely not by scoffing, negativity, and the bad attitudes of pundits, I suspect.

Buckley revived the conversation with a wry tip for Republicans. “I think that the ultimate strategic loss to the Republican Party of failing to act on the gay marriage amendment and sticking to their grounds on the matter of what constitutes a marriage conventionally understood would be a serious mistake,” he purred. “But all the cultural organs are in this direction (favoring gay marriage). They’re very hard to slow down. I don’t know whether Jack would encourage a move to authorize bestiality. I’m sure he wouldn’t as a matter of personal reaction. But whether he would find that the Constitution, in fact, permits it, becomes an open question.”

Germond couldn’t resist the fun. “Because if it’s OK with the Constitution, it’s OK with me.” Germond’s frown blossomed into a full-blown chuckle.

Fun, subtlety, collegiality, humor? In national politics? It was Sunday morning. Surely I was dreaming. (Beth Solomon is reachable at).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 14, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/071404.pdf?ref=smdp.com)