> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Personal attacks do nothing to foster public debate
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/personal-attacks-do-nothing-to-foster-public-debate/
- Published: 2004-07-20T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:23:02.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*DOSE OF*

*By REALITY BY MATTHEW GLASSER*

One of the best things about being a newspaper columnist is the flood of e-mails I receive in response to my columns. While I always appreciate the e-mails that praise my work or support my ideas, I especially enjoy the letters that express disagreement with my point of view. I’ve always believed that if you don’t upset people from time to time, you don’t really stand for anything. Dissent and debate is a healthy part of living in a democracy.

Unfortunately, in many cases, debate has been replaced by mean spirited and vicious personal attacks. It’s no longer good enough to say someone is wrong. Now you have to insult them, question their morality, and curse their home and family. And while many liberals claim that conservatives are the most mean spirited of them all, I’ve found that the most venomous attacks are coming from the so-called progressives or liberals.

You’ve heard the old adage, “hell hath no fury like a woman scorned.” Well, hell really hath no fury like an upset Santa Monican liberal. The residents of Santa Monica are certainly not shy when it comes to sharing their opinions. And when they are upset, they make sure you know it. But the far left wing of the Santa Monica populist tends to be the nastiest when it comes to expressing their disdain for a particular point of view.

I’ve been called a fascist, communist, liberal, conservative, humanitarian, racist, a Bush lover and a Bush basher. Apparently, opinions are also in the eye of the beholder. In response to one of my columns, I was both a war mongering conservative and a do-gooder liberal. Two people read the same words but had two very different perspectives on what I was trying to convey.

But it’s not the opinions expressed in these e-mails that I find most interesting. It’s the tone and language that the writers use. I love to debate public policy issues. I grew up debating politics around the dinner table and I am happy to debate different points of view when the arguments are based on facts. But the majority of the correspondence that I receive would rather attack me personally than engage in an intellectual debate of the issues.

I’ve been called names, been accused of racism, and even had my morality questioned.

It’s not enough for these people to tell me that they disagree with my point of view. These folks have to attack me personally in order to attack my opinions.

This leads me to believe that they can’t support their argument factually. So instead, they hurl insinuations and epitaphs my way.

I have a thick skin and I can handle the attacks. In fact, I find them amusing. But that’s not really the point. We have a lot of problems in this world and we need intelligent debate to develop solutions. The left, center, and right are going to have to be civil with each other and agree to compromise on solutions. As long as we live in an “us versus them” world, we’ll never get beyond accusations and name calling.

Here are just a few examples of the kind of responses I’ve received in regards to my columns: ■ When I questioned the filmmaking techniques of Michael Moore, several readers called me a Bush lover. One was upset because, in the exact words of the reader, the “truth pisses you off because your (sic) on the wrong side of it. You're just mad because your boy in the White House got creamed.”

First, Bush is certainly not “my” guy. I actually voted for Gore. And second, questioning the techniques that a film-maker uses to get his point across is not an endorsement for a particular point of view. It’s a reminder that we shouldn’t believe everything we see and hear. But more to the point, this type of response is typical of the letters I receive. This sort of demagoguery does nothing to address the problems that Moore addresses in his film. It’s simply a cowardly personal attack that adds nothing to the “market place of ideas.” ■ When I wrote a column comparing the problems of Santa Monica to Compton, I was accused by one reader of being a racist because I didn’t mention that Compton is mostly black and Santa Monica is mostly white. The point of the column was to remind Santa Monicans that life in the city by the sea isn’t so bad and other cities have much worse problems. I didn’t mention race because I didn’t want to insinuate that Compton’s problems were a result of a certain racial group. Isn’t the reader’s insinuation that a particular racial group is the source of city’s social problems more of racist commentary than my initial omission?

These are two examples of a much larger problem. Let’s stop calling each other names. Being on the left doesn’t mean you’re always right and it certainly doesn’t mean you are morally superior to people with different opinions. Next time you are tempted to hurl insults at someone with a different perspective, you might want to reconsider. Perhaps you should use that energy to actually make a difference on the issues you claim to care about. (Matthew Glasser by e-mail at)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 20, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/072004.pdf?ref=smdp.com)