> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Piecing together the perplexing family puzzle
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/piecing-together-the-perplexing-family-puzzle/
- Published: 2004-06-28T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:18:23.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By CAROLINE BODKIN*

Even before they were married last August, my older brother and his girl-friend, now wife, Gretchen, spent the holidays together. This meant she often spent them with our family.

They began dating at the end of their college careers, and after graduating moved together into my parents’house for a few months to save money before going on to the big city.

For obvious reasons, this wasn’t the best time for the new girl and parents to get to know each other: Two recent college grads, dating and living in a parent’s home, wanting to get out into the world. Parents dealing with two wild, creative (messy), eager-to-explore-the-world young minds right when they thought they’d earned an empty nest. I was away at school and knew no more than that my brother was in love. With whom was still a mystery.

So the new girl in town was still somewhat of a mystery at that first shared Thanksgiving.

My family, plus one, gathered to celebrate and welcome Gretchen to our table. At least, that was our perspective. From her seat, she might have been welcomed but it still wasn’t her table. We weren’t her family, though my brother was treating her as part of his. I’m sure she missed her parents back in New Hampshire, and maybe wondered if she’d ever feel a part of the group that surrounded her.

I remember sitting there, feeling one-third excited about my brother having found someone who seemed (though I hardly knew her) wonderful, one-third sorry for her, sitting quietly at a table with our very outspoken and quirky family. My other one-third was, I’m ashamed to say, irritated. My brother was bringing someone to Thanksgiving dinner? Um... he’s my brother. Who’s the new addition? Is she permanent?

In an attempt at conversation, or maybe a veiled attempt at keeping her separate, I remember asking “So... I guess your family has turkey too?”

Each family is its own puzzle, each member an odd piece of the whole. How could you add another piece without changing the picture? You can’t.

Bringing someone into your family picture is no easy task. Nor is it easy to enter into someone else’s — you end up feeling like the random cousin no one wanted around. And really, are we ever supposed to feel just as happy returning to someone else’s parents’ house for a holiday? Conversely, can we ever be fully relaxed bringing significant others into our picture lest they feel left out or, worse, disinterested in becoming part of it?

Time passes. People stay in love. Families continue making their history even as things change.

This summer we found ourselves again at my parents’ home for a family friend’s wedding and for us, things went on as usual. We hosted a shower, we went to brunch, we went hiking, and we bought gifts all as usual.

Gretchen and my brother were in the group photos... as usual?

At one point, I was sitting in the living room with my mom, knitting (yes, knitting) our first knitted items ever. Gretchen had just taught us how. I could hear she and my brother in the kitchen laughing about something while they made lemonade. We knitted, they laughed. My mom or I would call her in to help when one of us made a mistake. Dad returned with the extra bag of lemons Gretchen had requested.

That night she was involved and entertaining and her talkative, happy self at the table... as usual.

I don’t know how she became part of our family. Maybe their wedding did mean something, maybe it was the five years we’ve had to get to know her in spite of ourselves (myself). Somewhere along the line, she began to see what the puzzle of our family looks like — even what each piece looks like. And somewhere along the line, we learned about her unique shape, and as we did that, our puzzle reshaped itself to include her — even to join with her family to make a bigger picture. And now — it’s so strange — I honestly can’t imagine her not being there. Yes, there would be a hole without her.

Bringing someone into your family is no easy task. Nor is it easy to enter into someone else’s. Maybe it just happens. Maybe it just takes patience. Maybe it just takes enough times around the family table to realize that no table is too small that you can’t add another setting. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and will always make room at her table. You can ).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 28, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/062804.pdf?ref=smdp.com)