> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Prisoner abuse is not part of American way
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/prisoner-abuse-is-not-part-of-american-way/
- Published: 2005-06-15T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:15:48.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

(Editor’s note: Ed Silverstein is on vacation. This column was originally printed in May of 2004.) I want to start by doing what President Bush should have done — apologize to the Iraqis who were mistreated by American soldiers.

I’m sorry for what my country, under the leadership of President Bush, has done to you. It was sadistic and unforgivable and there is no excuse. I understand that any apology is entirely inadequate and that the United States can never make up for the mistreatment you endured.

I know this because my own father, at the age of 18, spent 14 months in a German P.O.W. camp during World War II. To this day, 60 years later, he still carries the psychological and physical scars.

My father’s P.O.W. camp also had abusive guards, or as Lindsey Graham (R- South Carolina) called them during the Senate investigation, “A few individuals having a little perverted fun.” But this “fun” left my father filled with hatred. And when he was liberated, he grabbed a rifle and went to murder one of those guards. Thankfully he couldn’t bring himself to pull the trigger. That was not the case with another group of POWs whose hate lead them to decapitate one of the other abusive guards. And, by my father’s own admission, the abuse he experienced at the hands of the Germans was far less than that suffered by the Iraqis and with none of the sexual humiliation.

Bush continues to maintain that these are isolated incidents. His cheerleaders, such as Rush Limbaugh, try to dismiss this torture as “frat house pranks.” I’d be curious to know what fraternity he attended and if the Big Fat Idiot — as Al Franken dubbed him — would feel the same if it was him handcuffed to the wall, stripped naked, sodomized and then ripped open by vicious dogs. Say, that does sound like “fun.”

Bush was right about one thing: This abuse is not representative of America. But it is representative of this Administration.

Let’s start with Bush’s contempt for civil rights. After 9/11, Attorney General John Ashcroft secretly rounded up 5,000 Muslims. They were held without due process or allowed to contact their families. Out of 5,000, only three were ever accused of crimes and only one convicted. In Iraq, military intelligence admits that 70 percent to 95 percent of those detained were arrested by mistake. Yet the military only began to release prisoners after the photos of abuse surfaced.

More damnable is the Bush Administration’s implicit support of torture. They have repeatedly turned over suspected terrorist prisoners to regimes or countries that condone torture. Such was the case of Maher Arar, a Canadian citizen who was born in Syria. Arar was pulled off his flight to Montreal when it made a stop at JFK, arrested, questioned for nine hours without a lawyer, jailed and deported to Syria, where it was well known that he would be tortured, all without the knowledge of the Canadian government. Arar was brutally tortured for more than 10 months, yet he maintains that he is innocent of any terrorist activity and cannot understand why this was allowed to happen.

Further, contrary to what the administration would like you to believe, the abuse of prisoners is not isolated to a single facility or even to a small group of soldiers. It is widespread and systemic.

The first reports of mistreatment — in this case it was Afghani prisoners — came out of Guantanamo Bay. But these revelations were largely ignored and resulted in little disciplinary action, sending a clear message that this behavior is acceptable.

So it seems disingenuous when Bush and others within his Administration express disgust and disbelief that such abuse could occur at Abu Ghraib and other facilities throughout Iraq. If nothing else, the Bush Administration’s attitude was responsible for creating an environment that fostered such abuse. But I believe they are far more complicit.

Charles J. Hanley, Associated Press’ Pulitzer Prize-winning correspondent, reported complaints of abuse starting in October of last year. The abuse began, maybe too coincidentally, about the same time that the Administration began to realize that there were no weapons of mass destruction. If we are to believe allegations that intelligence officers ordered MPs to soften up the prisoners for interrogation, it seems all too conceivable that those orders could have come from a Bush Administration that was becoming increasingly desperate to find WMDs.

Was Rumsfeld personally involved? Rumsfeld admits that he was aware of the abuse in January and that he notified the president that same month. Yet despite photos that clearly evidence serious criminal activity, not one of those soldiers was relieved of duty or charged in a Court Martial until the photographs became public.

Considering the Administration’s penchant for secrecy, it is unlikely, if not for the efforts of New Yorker magazine and CBS 60 Minutes II, that these photos would ever have seen the light of day. This leaves us to wonder, had these photos not surfaced, if any of those involved would have been punished.

In fact, it is beginning to look more like Rumsfeld was involved in a cover-up of what can only be described as war crimes. If this is true, the next question becomes — and this may sound familiar — what did President Bush know and when did he know it?

Even if Bush is not directly involved in condoning torture, it remains that leaders lead by example. And the example set by the George W. Bush is that it doesn’t matter if you break the law, ignore civil rights or do grievous harm as long as you get what you want. Maybe it’s time the president learned that that is not what America is all about. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer being held at an undisclosed location in Santa Monica. Comments can be sent to)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 15, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/061505.pdf?ref=smdp.com)