> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Quack, quack: Ducking questions kills a debate
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/quack-quack-ducking-questions-kills-a-debate/
- Published: 2004-10-02T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:04:15.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

Thursday night was the first of the presidential debates — or as they’re also known, “Which Candidate Can Duck Tough Questions The Best?”

These things are always more show business than actual debate, but this year, there’s a new wrinkle — one that isn’t covered by makeup. The candidates decided on the rules, and there are more rules than ever. Having them decide on the rules is a little ridiculous. It would be like players on a World Series team deciding on the rules for the series, or a criminal defendant deciding what evidence may be admitted, or a presidential candidate having his brother as the governor of the state that could swing a contested election. It’s too much of an “inside job.”

As they negotiated these rules, the big thing the Democrats wanted was to have three debates instead of two. The big thing the Republicans wanted was, understandably, a chance to make their guy look as good as possible. So, the Republicans gave in on the number of debates, and the Democrats gave in on some interesting details. Apparently, the Republicans were afraid that the taller Kerry would make Bush look too short. So, they insisted that the lecterns be a certain height and be farther apart so Kerry wouldn’t be looking down on Bush. At the same time, the rules specifically prohibited either candidate from using “any device to make them look taller.” What were they afraid of, that Bush was going to come in on stilts?

There is other minutia as well in the 32-page negotiated agreement (if people had put this much energy into negotiating foreign policy, the war in Iraq could probably have been avoided). The debaters could not use any “props.” I guess both candidates had to cancel those puppets they ordered. They could use any kind of pen or pencil to take notes, but these writing utensils had to be given to the debate staff before the debate began. That was probably to eliminate them bringing those combination pen-squirt guns.

The audience was able to see the warning lights when the speaker was getting close to the end of his allotted time. This was considered a concession to the Republicans who hoped it might embarrass the habitually long-winded Kerry. One Democratic strategist found this “undignified,” and “like a game show.” No kidding. This is a game show.

It’s actually more of a “reality” game show, but unlike the actual “reality shows,” there aren’t any consequences if the players mess up. What would have happened if they broke one of the rules? How would they have punished Kerry if he removed a folded-up map from his pocket? What could they have done to Bush if he wanted to stand on his tiptoes when he spoke?

The rules also were designed to eliminate any chance for spontaneity. Candidates were not allowed to ask each other questions. Too bad. Wouldn’t you have liked to see them grill each other?

According to the rules, the camera was supposed to remain on the person speaking, so we wouldn’t see the other guy yawning, checking his watch, or making faces at his opponent. But fortunately, the networks ignored this rule. So, we did get to see the Bush Smirk and the Kerry Stare. And those were about the only glimpses of these guys as actual humans.

Then there was the Big Rule — other than the insincere handshake before the debate begins — the candidates were not allowed to touch each other.

Where did that come from? Who was worried that they would touch each other during the debate? Did someone actually fear that one of them would walk over and punch the other guy? If so, how disappointing that they eliminated that possibility. That’s something America would watch — even if it were on Pay TV. In fact, instead of having debates, maybe they really should just have a fist fight. Both men are macho, athletic types, so neither would back down. I say, if they want to box each other, let them. After all, they’ve been wrestling each other in the mud for months. (Lloyd Garver has written for many television shows, ranging from “Sesame Street” to “Family Ties” to “Frasier.” He also has read many books, some of them in hardcover. He writes the “Modern Times” column for CBSnews.com’s opinion page and).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 2, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/100204.pdf?ref=smdp.com)