> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Rocky treatment for Marciano
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/rocky-treatment-for-marciano-editor/
- Published: 2004-10-13T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T05:17:19.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Shlomo Menkes Santa Monica*

Mr. Marciano has made some very misleading statements in order to make his case against Israel (SMDP, Oct. 11, page 6). He quotes Tony Judt as if he is the foremost expert and last word on the history of Israel and Edward Said, a well known anti- Semite.

Modern Israel is at war. It is a war that began not in 1967, with the repatriation of its ancient homeland, but in 1948\. It is fighting against people who want the Jews to leave the Jewish homeland.

Although Israel is the modern state of the Jewish people, it is not the beginning of the Jewish presence there. Three thousand years of uninterrupted and undeniable Jewish presence in Israel, which includes the land he calls “the occupied West Bank and Gaza,” would make the Jews the indigenous people of Israel. Jews are the “B’nai Yisrael” (children of Israel) and the “children of Israel” are from the land of Israel. Arabs are from Arabia. They arrived in Israel after Jews had lived there for close to 2,000 years. The language of Hebrew is the indigenous language of Israel. Jews are the only people who speak this language and have been doing so for over 3,300 years. To deny this is to deny history. Arabic is the language of the Arab people who come from Arabia. To deny this is to deny history. To call Israel “Palestine” and to call the Arabs living there “Palestinian” is to deny history. “Palestine” and “Palestinians” are words that have been created by those who want to deny the Jewish people their unalienable right to their homeland. The only “occupiers” in the land of Israel are Arabs and of course they deny that it is the Jewish people’s ancient homeland. The only colonizers in the middle east today are Arabs. Put another way: The Arabs living in Israel can be described as “indigenous” to Israel as I suspect Mr. Marciano would be described as “indigenous” to North America.

It is true that Israel would have an almost impossible task in remaining in its historical homeland without the help of the United States. I thank the people of this great country for that help. I dread thinking of the day Israel is left to stand alone against those same people, Arabs, who are today perpetrating colonization and genocide against the Africans of Sudan in Darfur and those who would attack the U.S. in the name of Islam.

The United States has gone against the opinions of the majority of the nations of the world for good reason. The Muslim Arab lobby in the U.N. is unequivocally and unambiguously against the existence of the state of Israel. They have banded together and used their immense wealth and power which is derived from the oil the world depends on to coerce and bribe countries dependent on them to vote in their favor. They include countries that are the breeding ground of international terrorism. They are countries that are involved in slave trade and genocide. These countries are undemocratic. They do not tolerate other religions in their midst and do not respect human rights. How many of these Arab Muslim countries share any of the values that we care so much about in the United States? I am proud of the moral compass used by the United States in its decision to stand with Israel.

Israel is fighting against “people” (I refuse to insult pigs as the woman on Pico Boulevard does) who are not bound, nor do they care about the conventions or agreements mentioned by Mr. Marciano. They use their hospitals and ambulances to store and transport weapons. They employ children to be human bombs and shields. They blow up unsuspecting men women and children, and dance in the streets in glee at the news of these bombings. I hope and pray and am sure that the good people of this earth “G-D’s garden” will stand together and put an end to the evil that justifies and rationalizes these “people’s” deeds.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 13, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/101304.pdf?ref=smdp.com)