> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Rules governing class action lawsuits need changing
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/rules-governing-class-action-lawsuits-need-changing/
- Published: 2003-07-16T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:22:04.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Ed Silverstein*

I need a lawyer. A good one. No, make that a great one. In fact I need the greatest lawyer in the world. The reason? I’m going to file a class action against all the other lawyers in the world.

Well, maybe not all of them, but definitely the class-action lawyers. These are the lawyers that one Florida judge compared to “the squeegee guys who frequent major urban intersections and who run up to a stopped car, splash soapy water on its perfectly clean windshield and expect payment for the uninvited service of wiping it off.”

Every U.S. citizen will be included in the class and we will be suing the lawyers for $45,407,000,000,000.

Now, you may be wondering how I arrived at this figure. According to the American Tort Reform Association, lawsuits in 2000 resulted in a cost of $1,200 for every adult and child. So I took the current population, about 290 million, multiplied that by $1,200, then multiplied that total by 40, which is approximately half our normal life expectancy. Finally, figure about 3 percent a year for inflation and there you have it: forty five trillion, four hundred and seven billion dollars.

Now some of you might say that class actions protect us from big corrupt corporations. This is true. But with lawyers becoming increasingly predatory, the cure may be worse than the disease. Take a look at some recent cases.

Asbestos. Some companies concealed known facts about the danger of asbestos and they deserved to be punished, but litigation put at least 15 companies out of business so far. Several of them were totally innocent. Thousands of workers lost their jobs. Billions were paid to plaintiffs, many of whom were not, and might never be, sick. And recent research has shown that many of the dangers associated with asbestos were exaggerated and in some cases non-existent.

Breast Implants. Not a single legitimate study has ever show any correlation between silicone breast implant leakage and increases in connective tissue disease, yet lawyers using junk science extorted $4 billion from Dow Chemicals and put them into chapter 11\. Smaller companies closed their doors forever. And guess what? The FDA is again considering approval of silicon-filled breast implants.

And then the granddaddy of them all: tobacco litigation.

As everyone knows, a bunch of states sued the tobacco companies for increased health care costs associated with smoking. Ultimately the tobacco companies settled for about $290 billion over 25 years. The first problem is that it’s all based on a lie. Smokers use less health resources because they die younger.

I’m not a big fan of tobacco companies. They produce a deadly product, advertise to kids, boost the nicotine to make it more addictive, use methods that misrepresent actual tar levels in low tar cigarettes and lied about it all under oath and in front of Congress. But does this settlement really punish them? The answer is no.

What they did was raise prices to cover the increased costs, so the only people really hurt were smokers… and of course the states bringing the suits.

True, these states are going to reap a huge windfall, but in fact they could just as easily have increased taxes on cigarettes, not only for the amount that they won, but the additional $70 billion that will shared by a small group of attorneys involved in the case.

And who are these lawyers? Well some of them had nothing to do with the litigation other than being a crony or big contributor to a state attorney general or other politician.

And if you think you’re going to get rich by being a member of a class action, think again. A typical settlement will usually result in a coupon for a few dollars off the very product that resulted in the suit in the first place. And when Bank of Boston was sued for escrow overcharges, customers were awarded about $10, but were charged $90 in legal fees for an $80 net loss.

What was really galling is that the loss for the plaintive resulted from their attorneys turning down the same offer two years prior because it would have paid them only $500,000 rather than $6 million in fees they ultimately received.

With war chests swollen by tobacco and other class action judgments, expect to see an increase in class action litigation. Plaintiff attorneys are already targeting paint companies, nursing homes, HMO’s, mold, not to mention fast food companies.

And because of the explosion in these suits we are being increasingly denied products and services. Playgrounds are being closed and Wendy’s has even stopped selling hot chocolate in the United States. And don’t be surprised if in the near future we are paying $5 for a McDonald’s hamburger and $70 for a gallon of paint.

And have you tried to buy insurance lately?

Class action tort reform is imperative. Congress is currently considering a law that would require class actions to be filed in federal court, thus eliminating shopping for venues that are plaintiff friendly. Another needed change is to require individuals to ‘opt in’ to a class action rather than being automatically included.

There is one reform, however, that would maintain the protections against abusive and dishonest corporate practices and yet would effectively curtail frivolous and opportunistic suits and those motivated purely by personal gain. Simply exclude plaintiffs and lawyers from collecting on punitive awards. Rather, use punitive damages to fund programs to insure that abuses that lead to the suit do not occur in the future.

Or we could just sue all the lawyers in the world. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Lawyers reading this column should be aware that opinions expressed in this column may not be those of the writer. Comments can be e-mailed to)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 16, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/071603.pdf?ref=smdp.com)