> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Salk’s shot in the arm did damage of its own
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/salks-shot-in-the-arm-did-damage-of-its-own/
- Published: 2004-09-15T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:00:53.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN*

On April 26, 1954, a single injection would mark the end of a scourge that had killed tens of thousands of children and left many others paralyzed or gasping for air in iron lungs. The Salk vaccine would soon rid the world of deadly polio epidemics and make its founder an American hero.

There was only one problem. Hidden within the vaccine was a deadly, cancer-causing, monkey virus.

Debbie Bookchin and Jim Schumacher, in their book “The Virus and the Vaccine,” detail the history of the polio vaccine and the virus it harbored. The biggest hurdle in creating the vaccine was that the poliovirus did not grow in normal substrates such as chicken eggs, but this was eventually overcome by using monkey kidneys. The problem was that kidneys are a cesspool of viruses, but, at the time, scientists widely believed that monkey viruses posed little threat to humans.

All of that should have changed in July of 1960 when Beatrice Eddy, a brilliant researcher working for the National Institute of Health (NIH), discovered contamination in the vaccines by a substance that would later be identified as simian virus 40, or SV 40\. More disturbing was that when the virus was injected into lab animals, it caused cancer in nearly every instance. Soon after, Maurice Hillerman, a scientist working at Merck, sounded a similar warning to the pharmaceutical industry.

Eddy reported her discovery to her boss, Joseph Smadel, who dismissed her findings and warned that the NIH would not support her if she published her work. When Eddy ignored the warning, she was removed from poliovirus research, stripped of her well-equipped lab and exiled to what had previously been a broom closet.

The monkey virus quickly faded from the public’s awareness.

But in 1994, another NIH researcher, Michele Carbone, made a shocking discovery. Carbone, now the leading expert in SV 40, detected the virus in a sample of malignant mesothelioma, a rare lung cancer associated with asbestos exposure that was virtually nonexistent prior to 1955\. Subsequent discoveries would link SV 40 to brain and nervous system cancers, non- Hodgkin’s lymphoma, acute leukemia and other cancers that have experienced skyrocketing rates since the 1970s and which often take decades to develop. Carbone believes that SV 40 may be one of the most deadly carcinogens known to man.

Yet the NIH showed little interest in Carbone’s discoveries and even suggested that the viruses he found in tumors were the result of contamination in his lab. The NIH eventually became so obstructive that Carbone had to leave to continue his research.

Even after dozens of other researchers duplicated Carbone’s experiments, the NIH remained resistant and sponsored studies designed to disprove Carbone’s assertions. However, the studies were conducted by scientists whose lack of exper-tise and poor methodology, along with the fact that at least one was on the payroll of several vaccine manufacturers, resulted in findings so tainted that peer-reviewed journals refused to publish them.

That is not to say the government believed the virus was harmless. Ed Haslam, in his book “Mary, Ferrie & The Monkey Virus,” assembles convincing proof that, not only was the government aware of the danger, but in 1960 they had set up a secret lab to research a cure.

Overseeing the lab was a preeminent physician who held a top security clearance — Alton Ochsner. There was also involvement by three men with no medical experience — Guy Banister, Clay Shaw and David Ferrie. All three had ties to a CIA cell in New Orleans and were implicated in the Kennedy assassination by D.A. Jim Garrison.

But it gets even stranger. Dr. Mary Sherman, an associate of Ochsner and a top cancer researcher, who supervised the research in the secret lab, was found murdered in her burning apartment, the apparent victim of a lurid sexual crime. But Haslam points out glaring inconsistencies and produces overwhelming evidence that Sherman’s murder was staged in order to cover up a tragic accident in the lab and to hide her involvement with the covert research.

But why would a government organization, charged with protecting the public, become involved with a cover-up lasting more than four decades?

Initially, it may have had to do with the fact that Eddy was a woman scientist when women scientists were not held in high regard. Ego also played a part. Smadel, as well as other prominent scientists, had put their reputations on the line in support of hurrying the Salk vaccine to the public. And to be fair, polio was one of the most horrific diseases imaginable, with the numbers of child victims increasing every year.

In addition, during the first wave of inoculations, one of the manufacturers — Cutter — had released a batch of tainted vaccines containing live polioviruses. Some 260 Americans contracted polio from the vaccine and most were left paralyzed. A new vaccine scare may have frightened parents off for good.

More recently, the motivation seems to be liability. Certainly the government was aware of the dangers associated with SV 40\. The manufacturers had been warned by their own scientists and continued to use monkey kidneys until 2000, even though there was a safe, though more costly, human-cell alternative as early as 1974.

But when you consider that nearly every American who was inoculated between 1954 and 1963 was infected with SV 40, and millions of others since, it seems unforgivable that the NIH and our government continue to obscure this vital information. But that may soon change.

The Bush administration, citing terrorist concerns, is trying to provide vaccine manufacturers immunity from civil suit. While this will allow these pharmaceutical giants to get away with murder, it may pave the way for the NIH to admit a problem exists and to allow funding for vitally needed research on SV 40\. But for many of us, it will be too little, too late. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in California and Montana. Comments can be sent to)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 15, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/091504.pdf?ref=smdp.com)