> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Santa Monica Clarifying Robertson’s legacy at SMC
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/santa-monica-clarifying-robertsons-legacy-at-smc-editor/
- Published: 2003-06-23T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T02:23:57.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Dennis Frisch History Department and China Study Tour coordinator Audrey Roche Chair, Business Education Department*

The article by Cattell-Luckenbach (“Santa Monica College president criticism is misdirected,” SMDP, June 17) makes a number of very misleading claims about the leadership of Dr. Piedad Robertson, president of Santa Monica College.

In a very general sense, Cattell-Luckenbach attributes to Dr. Robertson many accomplishments that were actually initiated and substantially accomplished under the leadership of the former president, Richard Moore.

In particular, the claims about the development and growth of the international students program are very misleading. The international students program (both attracting international students to Santa Monica College and developing study abroad programs) was begun under the former president and grew rapidly with his strong support. Dr. Robertson inherited a flourishing international students program and proceeded to seriously curtail the study abroad programs.

First, the senior administrator who worked very effectively under Richard Moore to attract faculty and participants to study abroad programs (in Europe, East Asia, South America, the Middle East) left the college under pressure from the new president, and the college has not offered the variety or number of study abroad programs since. Indeed, the only international study program initiated under Dr. Robertson was an ill-fated program with a college in the Republic of South Africa, which was ultimately discontinued.

More recently, Dr. Robertson has made several trips to South America or sent faculty to explore and promote new international study programs. To date, all this travel has produced no new international study programs.

It is also interesting to reflect on the claim made by Cattell-Luckenbach about the emergence of Santa Monica College as a highly respected community college known for its academic excellence and innovative approaches to higher education.

In fact, that too was an accomplishment of the former president. His vision of Santa Monica College as an institution offering the kind of academic programs found in institutions such as California State University-Northridge or UCLA, and vocational programs that opened up opportunities for students in a variety of important and rewarding careers, was strongly supported by both faculty and staff.

It was during those years that SMC acquired the reputation it currently enjoys. After Richard Moore announced his intention to retire and during the interview process for the selection of a new president, Dr. Robertson, in response to a question from a staff member asking why she wanted to be president of SMC, said explicitly that part of her motivation for applying was the reputation for innovation and excellence that SMC enjoyed nationally.

It appears that Cattell-Luckenbach has rewritten history a bit (in a misleading way) by asserting that Dr. Robertson was largely responsible for the transformation of Santa Monica College.

More revealing still is the fact that early on under the leadership of Dr. Robertson a very promising program called “Sabre” (a training program in computerized air-line check-in and reservation systems first created by American Airlines) was abandoned after the faculty and staff in the business department worked hard to create a vocational certificate program in partnership with American Airlines.

More recently the administration’s most dogged answer to the budget crisis was to reduce or eliminate programs, most notably such vocational programs as transportation technology (often known as automotive mechanics and repair), respiratory therapy and architectural interior design.

How, one might ask, do these actions (and many others) support claims that the leadership of the current president has embraced and promoted the mission of the California Community College System or, more particularly, Santa Monica College?

More seriously misleading is the claim made by Cattell-Luckenbach about college morale. The state legislature mandated in Assembly Bill 1725 (became law in 1988) that California community colleges incorporate into their governance structures shared governance. The state legislature was affirming and supporting the long, long tradition in higher education that college governance is a partnership between faculty, students, staff, and administrators.

This is an idea that dates back at least to the 12th century and the founding of the University of Paris and has been central to the evolution of higher education in the United States since the founding of the earliest American universities and colleges such as Harvard University and the College of William and Mary during the colonial period of our history.

Santa Monica College, even before the passage of AB1725 and, again, under the leadership of the former president, began to develop the institutional framework of shared governance. From the beginning of her tenure as president of SMC, Dr. Robertson has shown little or no sympathy for the ideas or practices of shared governance.

Contrary to Cattell-Luckenbach’s assertion that the state budget crisis produced a vote of no confidence, it was, in fact, the clear lack of support for shared governance to address what the faculty and staff recognized as a serious financial crisis for the college, that finally led to the recent vote of no confidence in the leadership of Dr. Robertson.

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 23, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/062303.pdf?ref=smdp.com)