> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Taking your lumps can be a good thing... or not
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/taking-your-lumps-can-be-a-good-thing-or-not/
- Published: 2004-03-18T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T04:02:34.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By John Kim*

Many companies today are offering their employees the option of taking a “lump sum” distribution from their retirement plans when they leave a company or retire. Having what may be a substantial sum of money all at once can give you a false sense of wealth. You now have to deal with such issues as taxation, your continued plans for retirement and your prospects for employment that could easily cut into your nest egg.

For many people, receiving a lump-sum distribution can be a temptation. You may think you “deserve” that new car, an expensive vacation or, perhaps, you want to be generous with gifts to family members. You may be under the misconception that the sum alone is large enough to support you during retirement.

In the instance you are not yet ready for retirement, you may even rationalize that you still have the opportunity to build up another retirement fund at another company.

These reactions are typical. According to a 2001 report from the AARP, fully 60 percent of 401(k) participants who change jobs take cash payments rather than roll their balances over into their new employers’ plan or an IRA, jeopardizing their long-term economic security. There seems to be little recognition among the general population that a lump-sum distribution comprises funds that were built up over the years and should remain earmarked for retirement.

One pervasive myth is that retirement represents just a small portion of your life. The reality is that we’re all going to live longer on average than our grandparents did. The National Center for Health Statistics reveals that Americans can expect to live nearly 20 years or more after they retire. This is not bad news. It simply means that the dollars you save during your working years must sustain you during your retirement years — more years than many of us may have been anticipating.

What steps can you take to better prepare for a secure and comfortable retirement? Since the largest single source of retirement funds will most likely come from your company’s retirement plan, such as a 401(k), it’s important to understand your options when you receive a lump-sum distribution.

Basically, there are four alternatives available to you: 1\. You may elect a direct rollover into an IRA. 2\. You may take receipt of the funds and then perform a rollover within 60 days. 3\. You may roll over a portion of the funds. 4.You may elect to receive the funds and pay current taxes on the distribution.

Here’s how a lump-sum distribution of $100,000 adds up under each scenario if you receive it when you are less than 59 years of age: CHOICE 1: DIRECT ROLLOVER INTO AN IRA If you transfer your distribution to an IRA or another qualified plan, your entire distribution will continue to grow tax deferred. $100,000 Plan distribution 0 Taxes withheld 0 Taxes owed $100,000 Total rolled over into an IRA CHOICE 2: 60-DAY ROLLOVER If you take your distribution and roll it over within 60 days, you will have to add back the 20 percent your employer was required to withhold in order for your entire distribution to continue growing tax deferred. $100,000 Plan distribution (20,000) 20 percent mandatory withholding\* $ 80,000 Distribution received $ 20,000 Withheld amount replaced with your own funds $100,000 Total rolled over within 60 days \* $20,000 may be refunded at tax time CHOICE 3: PARTIAL ROLLOVER If you roll over part of your distribution and take the remainder, you will defer taxes on the portion you roll over, and pay taxes, and possibly incur a penalty for early withdrawal if you are under age 59, on the portion you take. $100,000 Plan distribution (20,000) 20 percent mandatory withholding $ 80,000 Total rolled over within 60 days $20,000 20 percent withheld (7,000) 35 percent income tax on $20,000 withheld\*\* (2,000) 10 percent early withdrawal penalty on $20,000 withheld\*\* $11,000 Potential refund after taxes (cannot be rolled into an IRA) \* Assumes 35 percent tax bracket with 10 percent early withdrawal penalty CHOICE 4: NO ROLLOVER If you take your entire distribution in cash, you will pay taxes on the distribution (unless you qualify for a preferential tax treatment) and will probably pay a 10 percent tax penalty if you are under age 59\. $100,000 Plan distribution (35,000) Income tax (including 20 percent mandatory withholding) \*\*\* $(10,000) Early withdrawal penalty (under 59)\*\*\* $ 55,000 Amount of after-tax distribution \* Assumes 35 percent tax bracket with 10 percent early withdrawal penalty As you can readily see, you can keep as much as $100,000 of your distribution or only about half that amount (assuming you are in the tax bracket used in these examples), depending on the decisions you make.

The tax laws surrounding lump-sum distributions can be complex. Retirement plan-ning is a lifelong process, and you will likely encounter equally complicated decisions regarding distributions from your IRAs and perhaps additional lump-sum distributions throughout your lifetime. How can you manage this distribution process effectively? A prudent course is to seek professional help from a tax advisor, estate-planning attorney and a financial consultant before making any decision, which in many cases could be irrevocable. Once you run your own numbers and match them with your present situation and future goals, then you can see for yourself what choice is best in your individual circumstances.

The bottom line is that your future, and that of your family, depends on the intelligent retirement planning decisions you make today to preserve the value of your lump-sum distributions. (John S. Kim is a Financial Consultant with Smith Barney in Beverly Hills. For a complimentary retirement planning consultation, please call 310-205-4939 or visit his webpage at www.fc.smithbarney.com/jkim.

This article is based, in whole or in part, on information provided by the Individual Retirement Planning Services Department of Smith Barney. Smith Barney does not provide tax or legal advice. Please consult your tax and/or legal advisor for such guidance. Smith Barney is a division and service mark of Citigroup Global Markets, Inc. Member SIPC.)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 18, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/031804.pdf?ref=smdp.com)