> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The best of neighbors are those that can stay
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/the-best-of-neighbors-are-those-that-can-stay/
- Published: 2005-10-28T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:12:27.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By TED WINTERER*

One of these days I ought to get TiVo or some other digital recording device for my television, although first I should figure out how to program my cell phone and operate my daughter’s Leap Pad. Then I won’t ever miss Manchester United versus Arsenal, or Donald Trump firing some poor soul.

In the meantime, a dimwitted civic affairs junkie like me is grateful for CityTV, which broadcasts reruns of City Council sessions. And so, after returning from a trip to New England, I belatedly watched the Sept. 27 meeting of our elected leaders, which I was told was a liveli-er-than-usual affair.

And indeed it was, with 50 or so concerned citizens turning out to comment on the “Opportunities and Challenges” confronting us as City Hall revises its blueprint for land use and transportation for the next 20 years. Almost all of these residents were alarmed, as was I, by a report which described “moderate” growth as the addition in the next two decades of 8,800 housing units to the 49,297 already existing in Santa Monica.

So I watched with great interest the responses of our councilmembers, trying to read the tea leaves which might predict our future. I was gratified to hear City Councilman Kevin McKeown insist that growth was not the answer to the woes caused by growth and argue for preserving our current as-built heights and densities. And I was pleased that City Councilman Ken Genser acknowledged that keeping our city’s current scale is essential and offered ideas about curbing commercial growth, which is a primary contributor to traffic congestion.

However, I was troubled by the remarks of Mayor Pam O’Connor and City Councilman Richard Bloom, who seem determined to add height and density along transit corridors despite public sentiment in favor of maintaining current conditions. And O’Connor suggested that the motto “same neighbors, better neighborhoods” offered by several speakers was in some way xenophobic, as if those living here want to build a moat and wall around Santa Monica to deter newcomers.

I think she misconstrued the sentiment. The good citizens who spoke that night aren’t fretting about hordes of outsiders migrating to Santa Monica. Instead, they’re perturbed by the exodus of current residents, displaced by the market forces and land use policies which cause older, affordable rental stock to be replaced by expensive condos and apartments. Sure, every one of these new high end developments has to create some lower-income housing, but it’s not nearly enough. And, because of the way the funding rules are written, those units are often given to those who live outside the city rather than dislocated Santa Monicans.

Interestingly, at the same meeting City Councilman Herb Katz, with whom I often disagree regarding issues of growth and development, expressed concern that current trends will lead Santa Monica to become a city populated by only the rich and the poor, without a middle class. And he’s right: Our first Sustainable City Report Card, while it gives Santa Monica an “A” for its efforts to ensure “variety in the housing stock to meet the range of household income levels in the community,” bestows a grade of “D-” for the results.

While much of these woes are caused by vacancy decontrol and a superheated real estate market, one could also deduce that current municipal policies, while vigorous and well-intended, haven’t been effective. And we’re certainly not the only city battling to preserve socioeconomic diversity. In fact, two days after this council meeting The New York Times ran an article on a nascent movement in other cities “suffering from success” to build low-cost homes for purchase by median-income households, so that nurses, cops and teachers can live near their jobs.

So I’m delighted that this week our City Council approved for the first time the use of housing funds to build in the Pico neighborhood an affordable home-ownership development for those with moderate incomes. It’s a huge step forward, for it both adds an ownership option to the city’s housing portfolio and addresses the harsh reality that market-rate homes are now affordable only by the affluent.

But we need to do more, such as exploring new funding mechanisms for lower-and middle-income housing, which will give priority to Santa Monicans. And we require new land use policies that curb the growth of market rate dwellings beyond the reach of so many and instead foster a diversity of rental and ownership options.

Then the same neighbors, in better neighborhoods, will still be around to welcome the new arrivals to our town. (Ted Winterer is a writer who lives in Ocean Park. He)

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 28, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/102805.pdf?ref=smdp.com)