> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Republicans trip over themselves in individual states’ rights argument
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/the-republicans-trip-over-themselves-in-individual-states-rights-argument/
- Published: 2003-11-25T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T01:17:10.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Evelyn Jerome*

So what is it, Republicans? Do you support states’ rights or don’t you?

When it comes to restricting a woman’s right to an abortion, you are happy to allow states to place restrictions on women’s access to medical care that are more stringent than federal laws. And so women in South Dakota have to travel a ridiculous distance to see an abortion provider and then wait 24 hours before having the procedure, as if they have not thought about their decision before seeing the doc.

When the question is whether a state can include offensive symbols in their state flags, you are happy to throw up your arms and say, “It’s a state issue!” And so African-Americans in South Carolina must stand by, marginalized, while the Confederate flag waves peacefully in the breeze on grounds of their state capitols.

States’rights are a good thing, right? It allows the local community to create and enforce their own societal standards that may vary from national law.

But recently Republicans in Congress fought to deny California the right to enact tough environmental standards for small gas engines, like those in lawn-mowers and leaf blowers. Fought tooth and nail, I should say. Fought despite their favorite doctrine, states’ rights.

So I guess Congressional Republicans favor states’ rights when it’s convenient.

In my quest for consistency, I’m against states’ rights pretty much all the time. I think if you live in California or Connecticut, Maine or Florida, or anywhere in between, you should have the same rights as everyone else in the country.

I think the “united” part of “United States of America” is more important than the “states” part.

It’s sad that California’s representatives had to beg for Washington’s blessing for the right to keep our air clean, with Sens. Feinstein and Boxer leading the charge with the complete support of the new governor, in his first week on the job.

How embarrassing — the Republicans, caught in an inconsistency so fundamental as this — the way the Constitution is interpreted.

Here’s what should have happened: There are federal laws about small-engine emissions. California, which has always led the way in environmental protection, has tougher laws about these emissions. Instead of denying California the right to have tougher environmental protections, violating their states’ rights dogma, Congress could have adopted California’s tougher laws, saved face on the states’ rights issue and protected the environment, all at the same time.

Clearly their agenda does not call for true environmental protection. So much so that their interpretation of the Constitution is expendable.

The fact is that we all breathe the same air. And though California leads the way in tough environmental standards, we are really just the non-smoking section of the aircraft we call America. With Nevadans, Arizonans and Oregonians puffing away in row nine.

I wouldn’t abolish the individual states’ ability to create their own laws, but some things are better regulated in Washington because on some issues, we should all live under the same rules. Should Kansas students be taught creationism on the same level as evolution? Should Mississippi students have to listen to a Christian prayer read over the public address system in public school? Should women in Oklahoma have to get their husbands’ permission before having an abortion?

These are the real-life implications of states’ rights, a big Constitutional issue that can be broken down into day-to-day issues that affect all of us.

Last week, the Republicans in Congress tried to have it both ways, but were thwarted. Hopefully next time they’ll see the big picture and make good laws for all of us. We’re residents of California, but we’re citizens of the United States. (Evelyn Jerome is a communications consultant, a past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 25, 2003.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/112503.pdf?ref=smdp.com)