> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The tyranny of having too many options in life
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/the-tyranny-of-having-too-many-options-in-life/
- Published: 2005-01-17T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T23:01:40.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*COMMON SCENTS*

*By CAROLE ORLIN*

My living room walls have been a nondescript color for four years now. And they are bare of adornment. It’s not that I don’t want to fix this problem, nor that I don’t have the funds to do so. It’s just that there are so many choices that I get bogged down in making a decision. Do I want my walls antique white, off white, coffee-bean white (since when are coffee beans white?), eggshell, cloud 1, 2 or 3? (I can’t tell the difference between 1, 2 and 3, but it just might be that subtle difference that makes or breaks the room.) Do I want them evening sage, morning sage, sycamore green, silver birch, sunburst marigold? Do I want them to be bright and invigorating, or soft and soothing? Do I want to make a bold statement or a subtle statement? Do I want to be adventurous or traditional? I can hire a color consultant or interior designer and let them worry about it, but there are so many of them, how do I know I’ve chosen the best one? So my walls remain bleak and bare. I know that doing nothing is in itself a choice, but at least it hasn’t cost me a small fortune to keep it that way.

That dilemma sent me to do some research about the relatively recent phenomenon of choice overload. Barry Schwartz, Ph.D., from Swarthmore College, has written a book called “The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less.” Dr. Schwartz is frequently quoted in a surprising number of articles that have appeared on this subject. A key premise of the Schwartz book is that today’s world offers us more choices but less satisfaction.

Dr. Schwartz uses the example of the huge amount of choices facing him in each aisle of his local supermarket. He counted 85 different brands of crackers, 285 varieties of cookies — including 21 different kinds of chocolate chip cookies, 65 box drinks for kids, 40 options for toothpaste, 116 kinds of skin-care creams, 90 different cold remedies, and worst of all, 360 types of shampoos, gels, conditioners and mousses. I myself have pondered the dilemma of choosing a shampoo — either for volume or smoothness or sun protection. I have come to the conclusion that I will have to use three different shampoos each time I wash my hair to get all that I need.

Through his studies, Dr. Schwartz con-tends, “everyday decisions, big and small, have become increasingly complex due to the overwhelming abundance of choices. We assume more choice means better options and greater satisfaction, but choice overload can make us question our decisions. It can set us up for unrealisti-cally high expectations, and it can make us blame ourselves for any and all failures. This can lead to decision-making paralysis, anxiety and perpetual stress.”

When there are limitless choices, we have no excuse for failure. He talks of how choice can be liberating until it becomes too much. There are just so many hours in a day, and so much energy we can put out to sort through all the options of everything: from doorknobs to college choices, cell phones, 401K plans, insurance options, physicians, pension plans, etc.

Some researchers, according to writer Tori DeAngelis in an article last summer for the American Psychological Association, found that too much choice “can lead people to make simple snap judgments just to avoid the hassle of wading through confusing options.” She references an article in the Journal of Consumer Research by Alexander Chernev, Ph.D., which found that when people were offered variants of the same brand of toothpaste (cavity prevention, tartar control, whitening, etc.), they tended to switch to another brand that offered a single option. Chernev reported on four studies where he found that “the bigger the assortment, the harder it is for people to choose, except under one condition: When they enter with an articulated preference.” Frequently they choose what the 1978 Nobel Laureate in economics, Herbert Simon, Ph.D., referred to as a “satisficing” option, meaning going with the first decent choice that fits their preference as opposed to scanning all options until finding the perfect or “maximizing” one.

Prior to his book, Dr. Schwartz in a 2002 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology discusses the fact that people who strive for maximization are more prone to depression and perfectionism, are more likely to compare themselves negatively with others, and are more prone to regret than those who use satisficing strategies. Schwartz professes that “you may do slightly less well objectively, but you’ll feel better about the results.” And think of the time you will have saved to do other things. Schwartz fears that the profusion of choices we have can turn us into maximizers and thus prone to misery and depression.

Christopher Caldwell, book critic with The New Yorker magazine, during a recent review of Dr. Schwartz’s book, writes about a radio producer who got a promotion because he was a good decision-maker even though not all of his decisions worked out. He was hired because he was good at making decisions. The boss was less worried about occasional mess-ups than the daily paralysis of someone “too cowed by choice to choose at all.” After decades of research, Mr. Caldwell points out that most people are in fact terrible choosers. “They don’t know what they want, and the prospect of deciding often causes not just jitters but something like anguish,” he wrote. Perhaps those that cannot decide should turn to Robert Reich’s recent book, “The Future of Success.” Modern consumers can deal with their anguish by “outsourc-ing” choice and simply hire experts to assist them in making choices.

Despite all the drawbacks of choice overload, I have not for one moment forgotten how lucky I am to live in a society that allows freedom of choice. I can look at all these choices as an opportunity to decide which things are worth my time and can help me to learn more about who I am, what is important and what is the right choice at any given point in time. Not easy, but worth it. Now let’s see if all this translates into choosing a paint color for my living room. (Carole).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 17, 2005.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/011705.pdf?ref=smdp.com)