> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# ‘Tree huggers’ cloud Earth in search of greenbacks
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/tree-huggers-cloud-earth-in-search-of-greenbacks/
- Published: 2004-05-11T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T00:02:36.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By Matthew Glasser*

I stopped by the Santa Monica Festival two weeks ago. The official theme was protecting the environment. Which, in Santa Monica speak means “who can we blame for our problems?” Apparently, despite years of progress on environmental issues, the sky is still falling and we are all to blame for the sorry state of the environment.

It was quite endearing to see 6-and 7-year-olds carrying large banners, signs, and posters exclaiming that “UNOCAL has dirty hands” and “I pollute. I have dirty hands.” With all of these large props to carry and transport to the festival, it’s a good thing that the children’s parents drove them to the park in their gas guzzling SUVs. They needed the cargo room to bring their “BMW has dirty hands” signs home after the fair.

My favorite part of the festival was visiting the booth hosted by an environmental research group called, Redefining Progress. The City of Santa Monica hired this group to determine that Santa Monica residents use more of the planet’s resources than they should. Bad Santa Monicans.

At the festival, the group set up a booth to “educate” young people about the misuse, overuse, and improper use of environmental resources. Redefining Progress measures how people and cities use their resources by creating an “ecological footprint.” Apparently ours is bigger than that of the legendary Big Foots. According to this group, the average Santa Monican uses 20.5 acres of the earth’s resources. Redefining Progress says we are supposed to be using only 4.5 acres.

To illustrate its point, the group set up a computer at the festival so kids could determine their exact footprint. It seems that all of our footprints are larger than what the group feels is acceptable. I found it amusing to see the group’s representatives try to explain what “unsustainable” means to children. I know some adults who don’t know what that word means.

Here’s my problem with groups like Redefining Progress. Despite years of success in improving the quality of our environment, these organizations consistently claim that we are on the verge of ecological Armageddon. Do we still have work to do when it comes to the improving the environment? Absolutely. But we have made great strides over the last three decades and we should celebrate our successes as well as our failures.

For example: ■ Environmental activists love to complain about our air quality. But according to data from the Environmental Protection Agency, air quality, while far from perfect, has actually improved significantly over the last 20 years. Those gas guzzling SUVs may use a lot of gas but they give off significantly lower emissions than the cars and trucks of previous generations. And thanks to new and improved technology — a factor not considered in the long-term calculations pontificated by groups like Redefining Progress — emissions from factories and industries also has been reduced. ■ Environmental groups spend a lot of time arguing that we are in danger of running out of forested land. But according to environmental researchers Michael Sanera and Jane Shaw, authors of the book “Facts Not Fear: A Parent’s Guide to Teaching Children about the Environment,” “the United States is not in danger of running out of forested land. There is more wood grown in the U.S. than is cut each year, and the number of acres planted with trees goes up nearly every year.” ■ How about all of those calls for increased water conservation? You would think we are in danger of running out of water any day now. But you would be wrong. The amount of water in our ecosystem will always be the same because water is constantly recycled through evaporation and precipitation. Michael Sanera and Jane Shaw explain that the Earth “has more than enough water to meet human demands... (the problem is that) water is often found in the wrong place at the wrong time.”

I could go on and on debunking environmental myths but I would run out of room.

So why do all of these environmental groups continue to cry wolf when it comes to environmental issues? It has as much to do with money as it does with saving the planet.

If you’ve ever received a fundraising solicitation from one of thousands of environmental organizations seeking your money, you would be led to believe that we are making zero progress in confronting our environmental problems. That’s because these groups believe that they must maintain a permanent “it’s the end of the world as we know it” philosophy or risk a reduction in donations.

Sacramento Bee reporter Tom Knudson, in his investigative report entitled “Environment, Inc.,” found that “salaries for environmental leaders have never been higher. In 1999 — the most recent year for which comparable figures are available — chief executives at nine of the nation’s 10 largest environmental groups earned $200,000 and up, and one topped $300,000.”

Knudson goes on to explain that “money is flowing to conservation in unprecedented amounts, reaching $3.5 billion in 1999, up 94 percent from 1992\. But much of it is not actually used to protect the environment. Instead, it is siphoned off to pay for bureaucratic overhead and fundraising, including expensive direct-mail and telemarketing consultants.”

That’s something to think about the next time an environmental group tells your 6-year-old that he or she is to blame for the world’s problems. Rather than using scare tactics, can’t we teach our children about our environmental successes as well as our shortcomings?

If all they hear is how poorly we are doing when it comes to improving the environment, they will be overwhelmed with feelings of hopelessness and the belief that nothing can be done to make the world better. At that point, there is a real risk of them saying “why bother?” And that would be the greatest threat to our environment. (Matthew).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 11, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/051104.pdf?ref=smdp.com)