> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.smdp.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# When outsourcing becomes a personal affair
- URL: https://www.smdp.com/when-outsourcing-becomes-a-personal-affair/
- Published: 2004-08-04T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-23T04:47:37.000Z
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Opinion, Santa Monica, #archive-import

*By GUEST COMMENTARY BY DR. STEVEN M. MINTZ*

Outsourcing is just another example, like allowing illegal immigrants to receive driver’s licenses, of putting economic and political interests ahead of doing the right thing. We need to examine issues such as these from an ethical perspective. Is it right or wrong? Is it consistent with society’s values?

Most writers on the subject defend outsourcing based on economic considerations. Some say while jobs are sent overseas, ultimately more jobs are created at home and the countries benefiting from the outsourcing develop economically with more spending power. However, job displacement and social costs exist that should be considered before the trend of outsourcing jobs overseas threatens the long-term viability of our economic and educational systems.

The California legislature recently found that the United States has lost nearly 3 million jobs over the last three years, with at least 15 percent out-sourced to a foreign country. Outsourcing by the state and local technology sector is a growing trend, with an estimated $10 billion in net contract value subject to outsourcing to foreign countries in 2004\. By 2008, an estimated $23 billion will be subject to out-sourcing by this sector. According to Cynthia Kroll, senior regional economist at UC Berkeley, at least 14 million service sector jobs are at risk of being outsourced over the next decade.

The long-term effects are likely to be even greater unless actions are taken now to slow down the trend. There are important social costs to consider.

The key word is “responsibility.” Has anyone in government done a study of the long-term effects on our educational system? Should I, as a college professor, advise my students not to study computer programming or software development because when they are ready to graduate, those jobs will be handled primarily from India?

What should they study in college? How about accounting? They can learn tax preparation. Everyone pays taxes — right? Yes, but as Lou Dobbs reported recently on CNN, “Tax experts estimate between 150,000 and 200,000 American tax returns were prepared in India this year.”

What if it was your tax return? Would you want to know that the sensitive personal tax information given to your American preparer might be transmitted to someone in India (or wherever) who put the return together and transmitted it back to the United States? I sure would.

SB 1451, introduced by Sen. Liz Figueroa (D-California) on Feb. 19 addresses the risk of privacy when personal medical and financial information is transmitted online to overseas workers for processing. The bill ensures that confidential information regarding a California resident, such as social security and bank account numbers, tax information, and health information that is legally protected by confidentiality laws in California, will be protected when used by parties outside California.

The ethical issues of outsourcing were made very apparent when it was disclosed in an article in the San Francisco Chronicle on Oct. 22, 2003, that a Pakastani transcriber of medical information threatened a medical center in San Francisco with posting patients’ medical records online unless she received more money for her services. Although the matter was ultimately resolved, the dangers are all too apparent.

This is not an isolated situation. Lou Dobbs reported in May that U.S. software company SolidWorks Corp. found that a worker employed by its Indian outsourcing partner tried to sell its property to a competitor.

States are dealing with the issue as well. In May, the Tennessee Legislature prepared a bill that Gov. Phil Bredesen has signed, making it the first state to give businesses an incentive for not out-sourcing data entry and call-center work to cheaper offshore locales. The new law asks state procurement officials to give preference in bids for such services to contractors employing workers only in the United States.

AB 1829, by Assemblywoman Carol Liu, (D-La Canada Flintridge) prohibits California agencies or a local government from expending state-provided funds for contracted services unless the contractor certifies under law that all work will be performed by workers solely within the U.S.

Outsourcing potentially compromises the confidentiality of patient and tax client information, and the practice is unethical unless the consumer of the service is given the right to “opt out” of the arrangement. It’s time for those interested in this issue to address the ethical problems. (Dr. Steven M. Mintz is a visiting professor of accounting at Claremont McKenna College).

*Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 4, 2004.* [Read the original PDF.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/smdp%5Fbackissues/080404.pdf?ref=smdp.com)