Skip to content

Letter: Opposing Santa Monica's change from 'owner' to 'guardian' for pets

Published:

By Robert Goldman Santa Monica

We all want to do what is right for our pets. In fact, I believe the Santa Monica City Council wants to do what is “right” for the companion animals in our city. However, the members of the council will make a huge mistake if they change the language in city codes referring to the person responsible for pets from “owner” to “guardian.” Changing the language from owner to guardian will create chaos for owners, veterinarians, nonprofit animal shelters and the city of Santa Monica as they try to sort out legal rights and responsibilities of “guardians” versus owners. And who will suffer while the legal battles are being fought? Our pets will be the victims of this well-intentioned mistake. In the end, as taxpayers, we will pay for it as well. The medical care for our pets could be delayed while thousands of city dollars are spent defending and defining the term “guardian.”

The problem is that “guardian” has no defined meaning as it relates to animals. The courts will have to look to how the term applies to humans. This could mean pet owners will no longer have the right to make certain decisions regarding the medical care and well-being of their pets. Animal shelters, such as the SPCA, might not be able to perform spays, neutering or euthanasia without specific government or court authorizations. This will cause enormous confusion for everyone.

The bottom line is changing the city language to “guardian” creates many more legal problems than it solves. Changing the word will not change the way we treat our pets! Most people already consider their pets to be part of their families. Those who abuse their pets will continue to do so whether called an “owner” or a “guardian.” We already have laws that make it a crime to abuse animals. We do not need to codify “warm and fuzzy” language that may actually cause harmful delays in caring for our pets.

I respectfully request our city council to keep the human-animal bond intact. We shouldn’t be spending time trying to fix what isn’t broken.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 9, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe