Skip to content

Letter: Objections to school district goals and the race framing of a campus melee

Published:

By Derek Lantzsch

(see definition again above) 9. “Bid for outside experts to conduct residency patterns of youth who experience academic failure and assess the status of the neighborhoods in which they live.” Do we not have academic achieving students that come from all neighborhoods? Do we not have academic failing students that also come from all neighborhoods? Of course, it is not the neighborhood where you live but the effort you put into your learning that decides the results. 10. “Develop a model with community input to train school staff and parents on how to create an empowering learning environment for students.” Once again something I think we all support, and has been enforced long as I can remember as a goal of most every school.

The article quotes Ana Maria Jara as saying “This isn’t about African-Americans and Latinos fighting.” Well according to all accounts it is. I spoke personally with many members of the community from the Santa Monica chief of police to students who saw what took place, read the coverage and listened to media people investigating the melee. Not a single person has mentioned that any other race was involved. And each and every person I spoke to informed me that it was African- Americans against Latinos, or as the news reporter put it,“blacks against browns.” In fact, some reported that it was the Hispanics that started the racial offense.

To put our heads in the sand, or deny that the king has no clothes, does nothing to serve in identifying the solution to the problem. To hide from the facts is to allow them to fester and create more problems. Simple logic here is all it takes.

The article points out that the student body at Santa Monica High School “is 47 percent considered minority.” That the “staff and administration is largely white.” OK, so? This is no surprise, and, if you go to the Watts or Compton communities, you will see that the staff and faculty are largely the reflection of the community in which they serve. Santa Monica has more people of white color than any other color. This should not be shocking or a surprise, nor is it a reason to make changes. This reminds me of LA council person Mark Ridley Thomas’ comments on the radio a while back. When I asked him if a white qualified applicant could effectively serve in a black community, his answer was that “since it was a majority black community, that it would require qualified applicants who were also black.” Either Mr. Thomas is correct or incorrect. If he was correct, then the racial status we see today of the administration and staff at Santa Monica High School is also correct. This double standard of “if it benefits my race it is right” is not in the service of equality.

Finally, I wish to point out that if Mr. de la Torre wants to help, he needs to remember that we don’t fight fire with fire most of the time … we use water. To bring apparent gangsters to a school rife with gang violence is not in service of the greatest good. Where did the idea come from to bring in gangs to speak to students about not being in such? This is again contrary to logic.

Do we bring in burglars to speak about not burglarizing? Do we bring in dropouts to speak about staying in schools, or criminals to speak about going into police work? No, of course not.

It makes much more sense to bring in people who have not gone into crime, or have quit school. We want people who have worked hard to make something good of themselves. That is a true role model and where we must start and end with if you truly want positive change. This erroneous idea that we even want anything other than upstanding people to speak to our future citizens is not only damaging but outright stupidity.

I know that what I have covered here is not what some will even be open to, but it doesn’t matter as someone needs to speak up and tell the king:,“Yes king, you have no clothes and please put some on.”

Remember always that all people are people of color. We really have more in common than any of us ever acknowledge. White is a color. No one is translucent. As well, inside we are all of many colors. To stop others thinking in terms of colored and others not colored, we might cease using these terms all together.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 13, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe