By Edward Singer Santa Monica watching the protesters in Alabama think of them as zealots or freaks. In this society with its wall which separate government and religion, those who make the proverbial leap of faith are looked down upon. Being religious is simply not cool or hip.
The debate over the ten commandments’ appropriateness within public facilities, such as courthouses, has overlooked the commandments’ true importance. The Alabama debate which placed God as the centerpiece of the argument was a complete mistake. The ten commandments’ historical value provides more than enough justification for the ten commandments’ prominent placement in a public setting.
The ten commandments represent laws which the founding fathers considered when creating the laws of the United States. The ten commandments are a foundational document. If other foundational documents were provided for display would there be an uproar? Would anybody be upset if the Magna Carta was placed within a courthouse? Doubtful.
The ten commandment’s debate leads to more intriguing questions. The first being why are the ten commandments so offensive to our secular public, politicians and judiciary? The ten commandments are a remarkable set of laws. It is a set of laws believed to be delivered onto the Hebrew tribe from what is believed to be the creator of the human race and the universe. It is this creator, who, prior to the issuance of the ten commandments, had the opportunity to view generations of humans and their interactions with each other and the world. It is this creator who saw both the good and bad of the human species. It is this creator who felt it necessary to lay out these laws in order to elevate the humans. This concept, even if one is secular, provides illumination to our relationship with the world. The additional beauty of the ten commandments is that they are unadulterated. They were not polluted by special interest groups, not pushed by politicians seeking to get reelected at all costs; and not subject to judicial scrutiny as to their constitutionality. If the ten commandments would be offered as legislation within our society, they would certainly be shot down. The likes of President Clinton and Gary Condit would take care of the adultery commandment. Corporations such as Enron, Worldcom and accounting firms would shoot down the commandments concerning bearing false witness and stealing. The AARP would insist that “honor your mother and father” be amended for a prescription drug benefits which we cannot afford. Federal judges would be offended by the fact that God declares himself as God when it is these lifetime appointed judges who have been accused of believing they were gods within their courtrooms. Poverty groups would be offended by the commandment not coveting thy neighbor’s possessions due to their persistent desire to redistribute wealth.
Regardless of whether one is religious or not, the ten commandments contain many things which our society should value. The commandments represent morality and justice as well as purity within law. The fact that people believe that the “Rule of Law” has divine inspiration is of importance and should not be ignored.
For those who doubt the historical importance of the ten commandments, please be advised that one could argue the following legal concepts were in part inspired by the ten commandments: The abolition of slavery, the separation of church and state, i.e., the concept of a society in which there was no human as being a divine ruler. Kings, labor laws providing all workers being provided a days rest, laws concerning the humane treatment of animals (the commandments provide that working animals were also entitled to the Sabbath day off, prohibitions on theft and murder, the concept of perjury and the value of the truth as a means of justice, equal protection and treatment for all individuals, the protection of property rights, and the protection of the elderly.) With all the relevancy of these commandments to concepts that persist throughout our society, the fact that they were delivered to humankind thousands of years ago is remarkable. In fact, some might say divine.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 11, 2003. Read the original PDF.