By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
While the 2008 presidential election may seem like a distant event far off in the future, the jockeying for the nominations has already begun. The primary season officially kicks off the day after the 2006 midterm election and serious contenders know that they must begin raising money, engaging the media and courting voters in the hopes of winning their party’s nomination starting then.
These facts are driving the Democrats towards trying to resolve the tension that has cropped up in the party over the primary calendar. Michigan Senator Carl Levin has urged the party to reevaluate the order of the different states’ primaries and caucuses because Iowa and New Hampshire have little racial or ethnic diversity. A party commission has been looking into it and their final meeting is set for Dec. 10.
While there is nothing ostensibly wrong with wanting to increase the diversity of the states that “go first,” it seems as though Sen. Levin wasn’t following things in 2004. On Feb. 3, 2004, the first weekend after New Hampshire, there were seven states that voted that day and at least three of them — Arizona, New Mexico and South Carolina — had very diverse electorates.
John Kerry won the nomination not because New Hampshire voters looked terribly different from Arizona voters, but because Kerry won both Iowa and New Hampshire. Kerry had what the media call “momentum” and he would have had it whether the first two states had been Colorado and California, or Alabama and Arkansas.
For the media, if you win two out of two, you’re on a roll. And that is what the voters in the other states responded to — media hype about being on a roll. In three of the Feb. 3 states — North Dakota, Missouri and Delaware — Kerry won a majority of the votes cast and he had rarely, if ever, even visited those places.
The only states on Feb. 3 that did not go for Kerry were South Carolina and Oklahoma. They went for John Edwards and Wesley Clark, respectively. And that had to do with the campaigns — Edwards and Clark’s campaigns, which had been positioned in South Carolina and Oklahoma for months before the election. Media hype wasn’t going to change those voters’ minds.
Michigan, which voted on Feb. 7, was largely ignored by the media because by that point Kerry had won “seven of the nine” elections that had run previously. In short, it was the frontloading of elections that doomed Michigan’s importance, not the state’s diversity.
No offense to Sen. Levin — he does a lot of great things on foreign policy — but it’s time to state the obvious. With the exception of Senator Carol Moseley- Braun, all of the candidates running were white males over fifty years of age, and with the exception of Senator Joe Lieberman, all of them were Protestant.
Does he really think that a diverse electorate will make a difference in the choice of the party’s nominee? That logic flies in the face of successful candidates like Sens. Barack Obama and Ken Salazar who often did better than their white opponents in the rural areas of their states with those white electorates. It also negates the achievements of successful incumbents like Kansas Governor Kathleen Sebelius who has shown that she doesn’t need to the voters to be liberal in order to support a woman.
Here’s The Thing: The Democratic Party has tied itself in knots making all sorts of arguments that quite frankly do not have a sound basis in political science research (see article: “Leeches, Lemmings, and Pet Rocks: The 2004 Democratic Nomination Campaign” available at: http://www.larambrown-phd.com/polisci.cfm), even though the commission studying the primary calendar heard from several scholars about ways to optimize the nomination process.
The New Hampshire Democratic Party has put forth a compromise plan that offers to put two states with diverse populations (of the committee’s choosing) just after its primary on the calendar. It also suggests that the Democrats slow down their entire nomination process by limiting the number of delegates that are up for grabs on each successive election date. Given the issues that arose in 2004, this plan is entirely logical and it offers the Democrats an opportunity to stop what has been their biggest problem — front-loading and overheated momentum — in its tracks.
For those of you who think frontload-ing is good, let me just remind you that former two-term President Bill Clinton never would have been the party’s nominee had the system been in 1992 what it was in 2004. Clinton did not win his first primary until Georgia on March 3, three weeks and three contests after Iowa. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and teaches at California State University, Channel Islands. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 2, 2005. Read the original PDF.