Skip to content

9-11 attacks painful for all, not just some

Published:

By Julia Reeves Santa Monica Some questions for NASA Editor:

I had a series of reactions to the guest commentary by Harriet Pike Epstein (SMDP, Sept. 11, page 5). First, let me just say to her that I am so very sorry that she had to experience first hand the horror of those tragic events of 9-11-01. Having said that, however, let me add that I am extremely offended by her claim to be more authentic in her experience of the pain and suffering of that day than the rest of the country who did not witness first hand the events. This isn’t just her nation that this happened to. It is our nation that this happened to and it will never be forgotten. It was probably one of the blackest days in the history of this country, if not the blackest.

I was born and raised in New York, worked for a time in Manhattan, and visited the World Trade Center on one of my return visits to New York. I have family and friends who live in New York. I have one relative who lives just across the river and could see it all happening. I lived the horror of that day in my own heart and I suffered along with the victims of those atrocities. For Ms. Epstein to presume to say “How can you presume to write about your 9-11 memory?” is a searing attack against my body and soul. Although I cannot speak for anyone else, I would dare to venture a guess that other Americans might be equally offended by her refusal to acknowledge the degree and depth of our pain and suffering.

To compare the television coverage on that day to be “like viewing a painting of a picnic” is ludicrous. What does she know about the emotions of other people, no matter how near or far away on that day? She is the one who is being presumptuous and jealously guarding her own pain, and suffering and disavowing everyone else’s. This is extremely hurtful and painful to me because I have suffered a great deal along with, no doubt, countless other Americans, from those hateful crimes against humanity that were carried out that day by those 19 murderous hijackers.

Her experience was very traumatic, to say the least, but, it was traumatic for the rest of the country also, and for her to minimize what other people felt is an outrage and arrogant. I wish I could have more empathy for her, but, sadly I don’t feel any more sadness for her than I do for myself and all other Americans. Don’t ever underestimate the power of the connectedness between all Americans, and the depths of our despair. Perhaps she is working through the trauma of it all, and can’t see beyond the end of her nose.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 13, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe