Skip to content

A claws for concern

Published:

By Jennifer Conrad Santa Monica

I am a Santa Monica veterinarian. I urge the Santa Monica City Council to adopt an ordinance, as proposed at a recent City Council meeting, to ban declawing of cats and other animals. Declawing is a surgical procedure in which the animal’s toes are amputated at the last joint. Most people do not realize that a portion of the bone — not just the nail-is removed. Declawing may result in permanent lameness, arthritis, and other long-term complications. It is illegal in many countries and considered unethical by veterinarians in most other nations of the civilized world.

The Veterinarian’s Oath can be distilled into one simple idea: Above all, do no harm. My interpretation of the oath is that, as a veterinarian, I am responsible for my patients’ welfare and am accountable for my actions. Veterinarians have an obligation to do what is best for the animals, not what is convenient for their owners.

Routine declawing (unlike sterilization) is never performed for the sake of the animal. It is done primarily to protect sofas and furnishings. There is no evidence that declawing provides protection from abandonment or euthanasia for the cat population as a whole. Scientific evidence suggests that declawed cats are actually at a higher risk for relinquishment to pounds (where 70 percent of them will be euthanized). This is likely due to unwanted behavioral problems, such as biting and litterbox avoidance, which have been shown to be associated with declawing.

Another widely perpetuated myth is the misconception that veterinarians must declaw cats to protect immunocompromised persons. However, the CDC, the U.S. Public Health Service, and leading infectious diseases specialists state that declawing is neither necessary nor effective in preventing the spread of diseases from cats to humans.

It is unfortunately common for some of our local veterinary clinics to agree to declaw a cat without adequately offering alternatives or client education. This is in contradiction to AVMA guidelines, and speaks to the fact that there are some practitioners who hold their own agendas over the well-being of animals. We as veterinarians must serve as our patients’ advocates and teach clients safe and humane alternatives, such as routine nail trimming and the use of nail caps, sticky tape and scratching posts.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 10, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe